A circa-1897 Huntington Bay residence listed for $4.5 million was built for banker Edward P. Alling, say local historians.

The seven-bedroom home with four full baths and two half-baths was built in tandem with a neighboring cottage for Pennsylvania Railroad executive John T. Robb. Both were designed by Carnegie Hall architect William Burnett Tuthill.

Home Search

Search Newsday for over 100,000 homes

“They started to compete with each other — who could have the bigger and better home,” says listing agent William Tarantola of Coach Realtors, who is co-listing the home with Elizabeth Alessio. “The appointments on these houses are incredible.”

As updates were made to the home, original leaded glass windows, enameled sinks and solid-oak doors were saved and can be restored by the next owner, Tarantola says.

Visitors arrive to a porte-cochère and mahogany foyer with a fireplace, leaded-glass windows and Huntington Harbor views through the back of the house. High ceilings, French and pocket doors and built-in furnishings are found throughout.

Upstairs, a master-bedroom suite — one of four bedrooms on the level — has a water-facing balcony, fireplace, marble and mahogany bath, walk-in closets and a dressing room.

advertisement | advertise on newsday

A finished third floor with a glass cupola and stained glass is accessible by an original service staircase and has three bedrooms, two walk-in closets, a full bath and a lounge in the gambrel.

The 1.62-acre property includes a column-lined covered porch, herringbone red-brick patio, 190 feet of beachfront land and a new sea wall. There is also a guest cottage with a two-car garage.

Deeded dock and beach rights are available to dues-paying members of the Nathan Hale Beach Association.

CORRECTION: A previous version of this story misidentifed the owner and his neighbor.