Sellers: Tim and Christina McElroy

Address: 40 Colonial Dr., Aquebogue

Home Search

Search Newsday for over 100,000 homes

Asking price: $469,000

The basics: A three-bedroom, two-bath cape on a one-acre lot

The competition: A three-bedroom, two-bath Contemporary on Trout Brook Lane is listed for $424,000.

Tim McElroy with his daughter, Morgan, 3, stand in the living room that features a wood burning fireplace on March 11, 2017. Photo Credit: Randee Daddona

Recent sale in the area: A three-bedroom, 2½-bath Colonial on Colonial Drive sold Dec. 12 for $385,000.

advertisement | advertise on newsday

Taxes: $8,931 ($8,139 with STAR)

Time on the market: Since Feb. 25

Listing agent: Janet Bidwell and Pamela Hogrefe, Douglas Elliman Real Estate, Mattituck, 631-298-6135

Why it’s for sale: Tim, 38, a special-education teacher, and Christina, 35, an occupational therapist, say they’re looking to buy a larger home.

A recently renovated kitchen in the McElroy home in Aquebogue on March, 11, 2017. Photo Credit: Randee Daddona

The McElroys’ home is in the middle of the North Fork’s wine country. It was built in 1978 and purchased by them in 2007. Tim says:

“The focal point when you walk in is the living room and the wood-burning fireplace. We just redid the kitchen with tumbled marble flooring, stainless steel appliances and granite counters. The kitchen looks out onto the backyard.

"The property is unique. There’s a farm across the street and a tree farm behind us, so we’re surrounded by farms. Only half the backyard is landscaped, the rest is natural. We have a deck that’s off the kitchen where we barbecue all year long. I built a three-section raised box bed for vegetables that has its own built-in irrigation ...

"We also renovated the hallway bathroom. We put in a custom vanity, white subway tile, a marble floor and a pocket door. The master bedroom has its own bathroom ...

"There are two huge bonus rooms upstairs. One room we use as second den where our girls play. And we’ve used it for entertaining. The space is currently unheated, but can be easily converted to two large bedrooms ...

Upstairs is a large bonus room that was being used as a playroom and den on March 11, 2017. Photo Credit: Randee Daddona

"The neighborhood is excellent and extremely quiet. You can walk to the Bayview Farm Stand. The neighbors are friendly and outgoing and willing to help anyone. We’re within walking distance to Paumanok Vineyards Jamesport Vineyards, and Woodside Orchards.”