Chapter 4: The Revolution
Christopher Vail's Revolution
In the summer of 1775, with the news of Lexington and Concord fresh in their memories, the aroused American colonies stood on the threshold of revolution. Those who chose to fight in the new Continental Army stepped forward, one by one.
The Plot to Kidnap Washington
A miserably bungled plot to kidnap George Washington and assassinate his chief officers led to the hanging of one of his special guards, the jailing of the mayor of New York, and a stepped-up search for Loyalists on Long Island.
The Patriots' First Big Test
On Flatbush Road, near the village of Brooklyn, 18-year-old Michael Graham looked death in the face. It was early in the afternoon of Aug. 27, 1776, and the Pennsylvania farm boy was facing a frightening British and Hessian onslaught.
Days of Defeat
As he stood on a Brooklyn hill watching the first great battle of the Revolutionary War taking place below him, Gen. George Washington is reported to have said: ``Good God! What brave fellows I must this day lose!''
Alive to Fight Another Day
For Gen. George Washington, the task now was not to win the battle, but to save his army. On Thursday morning, Aug. 29, 1776, Washington ordered that all available boats be brought across the East River to Brooklyn Ferry. For the operation he had in mind, the general had the good luck to have two regiments of expert Massachusetts fishermen available, from Marblehead and Salem.
A Hero's Last Words
Schools are named for him, an honor reserved for heroes. Textbooks cite him as a model of patriotism during the Revolutionary War. Every Memorial Day, the American Legion stops at his gravesite in Mastic to pay him respect.
Long Island's 7-Year Hitch
There is a knock on the door and the woman of the house hurries to answer it. In front of her stands a finely dressed British officer. ``Well, madam,'' he says politely, ``I've come to take a billet on your house.''
A Divided Hempstead
In 1775, civil war erupted in the Town of Hempstead. It was a war of words between Loyalists in the south and Patriots in the north, but it was nasty enough to permanently split the town.
Flag of a Different Stripe
As visitors swarmed into the New York World's Fair in 1940 they were stopped in their tracks when they came to the Long Island exhibit. They saw a ragged old American flag with the inscription: ``The John Hulbert Flag -- Original Stars and Stripes.''
Those Despicable Deadbeats
Lt. Col. Banastre Tarleton brought his Loyalist British Legion into Smithtown on a foraging expedition in November, 1778. He left town a few days later, despised and reviled as an arrogant and ruthless interloper. Also, a cheapskate.
Huntington Takes On the King
In 1775, no one was more active in the Patriot cause than Gilbert Potter of Huntington, a medical doctor who had served in the French and Indian War. Potter, who a year later would be named a lieutenant colonel in charge of the western regiment of Suffolk militia, wrote to Congress Dec. 10, begging for more than the 100 pounds of gunpowder it had allotted Huntington in September. He wrote:
The Man Huntington Loved to Hate
If a Gallup Poll had been taken in Huntington in the winter of 1782-83, Benjamin Thompson would have been the unanimous choice for the most despicable man in town.
Nathan Hale: Failed Spy, Superb Patriot
In the pantheon of revolutionary heroes there stands a flaxen-haired, blue-eyed young man, a handsome former schoolteacher, fair of skin and athletic in build, full of hope and promise, fated for an untimely death. He was Nathan Hale.
A Ruse Saves the French Fleet
Four years after the botched attempt at spying on the British ended with Nathan Hale's execution, Gen. George Washington needed his Long Island spies. In the summer of 1780, the British were threatening Rhode Island.
Washington's Eyes and Ears
Spying was risky business. Gen. George Washington wanted the newly recruited Culper Spy Ring to be aware of just how risky it was.
Crafty Codes of American Spies
Fearing that their messages might get intercepted by the British, the Culper spies quickly resorted to both secret code and invisible ink.
The Mystery of Agent 355
This grotesque headline, sad and yet deliciously wicked, appeared in the Brooklyn Eagle on May 30, 1948.
Passionate About the Past
One of the Culper Spy Ring's deepest secrets eluded historical detectives for almost a century and a half. The real name of the spy known as Culper Jr. was not uncovered until 1939, and the sleuth was a dedicated amateur historian named Morton Pennypacker.
Whaleboat Warfare
At 1 p.m. on May 23, 1777, the Patriots began striking back at occupied Long Island.
Leading the Charge
Here is how William Patchin, a 19-year-old foot soldier from Connecticut, saw his commanding officer, Maj. Benjamin Tallmadge of Setauket:
History Is Her Fort
A spent musketball embedded in a clear plastic block hangs from a wall in a church foyer. A red sandstone headstone of a long-dead soldier rests in the garden wall of a Victorian estate. And a corner of a back lawn rises into a grassy mound half the size of a tennis court.
Revolution's Unseen Rebels
When the war came in the summer of 1776, Benjamin Whitecuff and his older brother, both free blacks, worked on their father's 60-acre farm near Hempstead. But they were on opposite sides of the war. Whitecuff became a spy for the British; his father and brother joined the Continental army.
A Slave and a Poet
A few years after the end of the Revolutionary War, America's first black poet sat in his slave quarters on Lloyd's Neck and composed an eloquent address to his brethren. He looked back at the war and the cause of liberty for which it was fought, and concluded that liberty should be not only be for whites, but for his fellow slaves as well.
The Wretched Prison Ships
More Americans died in British prison ships in New York Harbor than in all the battles of the Revolutionary War.
They Signed for Independence
ON Aug. 10, 1776, William Floyd of Mastic sat down in his room at Mary House's Philadelphia boarding house and wrote a worried and urgent letter. It is not known to whom he wrote, but apparently the letter was to someone in New York City. A week earlier, Floyd and others in the Continental Congress had provoked King George III by signing the Declaration of Independence.
Madison's Unrequited Love
It had all the makings of a romance novel. Passion. Power. Betrayal. While he was tending to the business of a renegade colony, 31-year-old James Madison fell in love with 15-year-old Kitty Floyd, the daughter of William Floyd and one of the most beautiful women the future president had ever seen.
A Long Island Exodus
Sarah Frost began her exile as a Loyalist seven months pregnant. She boarded the ship Two Sisters at Lloyd's Neck on May 25, 1783, with her husband, William, and their two children. On June 28 they arrived at the Bay of Fundy, at the mouth of the Saint John River, in Nova Scotia.
America Celebrates Its New Freedom
As his boat was being rowed out into New York Harbor from the southern tip of Manhattan, Hessian Capt. Johann Ewald looked back on the land he was leaving after seven years of war. Slender and erect in his green coat and vest, with carmine red collar, cuffs and lapels, Ewald had been known for his compassion as well as his courage, but on this day he was just another defeated soldier who had survived.
Washington Says Thanks
The war was over, and Lt. Col. Benjamin Tallmadge was going home to Setauket. But first, he had to say goodbye to his general.
Our Towns
This special online section combines community profiles with historical snapshots and maps from the turn of the century. Clicking through the section reveals just how much Long Island and Queens have changed over 100 years.
Popular stories
- Body found in Wantagh park
- Kennedy Airport runway to be closed for 4 months
- Fire closes Throgs Neck Bridge
- Man fatally struck by LIRR train
- LI cops praise their canine partners' police work


