Andi Dorfman had a tough time on "The Bachelor," when she got fed up with Juan Pablo Galavis and his shenanigans. She quickly became one of the most-loved girls on the season, which landed her the role as "The Bachelorette" -- but is that what she wanted all along?

advertisement | advertise on newsday

John Busing, 30, and Dorfman, 26, dated right before "The Bachelor" began -- she actually broke up with him when she found out she was cast on Galavis' season, a source close to Busing told exclusively.

We know that he was actually devastated when they split -- he thought they were going to get married after dating for about four years. On "The Bachlorette" premiere, when Dorfman met Josh Murray, ex-pro baseball player, she said he was definitely her type -- and now we can tell why. Busing was an athlete, too -- he went from Miami University to the Cincinnati Bengals, the Houston Texans, then the New York Giants.