Verne Gay Verne Gay

Gay is the television critic.

THE SHOW "The Mentalist"

WHEN|WHERE Tonight at 9 on CBS/2

REASON TO WATCH Simon Baker

WHAT IT'S ABOUT Patrick Jane (Baker), our mentalist, is a searing, smart

cop who, from the tiniest details, gleans great cosmic truths about people's

lives and - because he's also a cop - their motives. Comparisons to Sherlock

Holmes are apt, except he's doesn't have his Dr. Watson; Jane's more of a

soloist, a slightly chilled, distant personality who has an uncanny ability to

advertisement | advertise on newsday

see into everyone else's heart except his own.

He's suffered a horrific loss - details of which will unfold - and as a

result doesn't want to look too closely inside. (And yes, by now you're

thinking of House, too.) The other cops he works with tolerate Mr. Know-it-all

because he is so bright. Tonight, there's a brutal double homicide that may be

Sign up for Newsday's Entertainment newsletter

Get the latest on celebs, TV and more.

the work of serial killer "Red John," so named because he draws a smiley face

with his victim's blood at each of his crime scenes.

BOTTOM LINE You've got to admire CBS' tenacity with Simon Baker. At least I

do. He's an immensely attractive, telegenic actor who screams out "big star"

in every line on his face, and in every strand of his golden, tousled hair.

advertisement | advertise on newsday

First, "The Guardian" - a good show, perhaps even a very good one - then

"Smith" (not bad, either), and now, finally this. Is three Baker's (and CBS')

lucky number? Not sure. His strength can also be his weakness: Remote and

somewhat icy suggests "deep" and "exotic," but also "standoffish."

Tonight's pilot is briskly competent. The formula - must find murderer of

advertisement | advertise on newsday

beautiful woman before last commercial break - predates the dinosaurs, but also

incorporates some satisfying twists. Watch by all means - just wear a sweater

when you do.

GRADE B