'I Love Lucy Christmas Special' review: Color isn't heresy
VideosRoslyn actress plays Lucille Ball in Stony Brook musical theater production 'I Love Lucy' in living color
Web linksTV Zone blog
THE SHOW "I Love Lucy Christmas Special"
WHEN | WHERE Friday night at 8 on CBS/2
WHAT IT'S ABOUT It's Christmas, it's color, it's Lucy -- nuff said? Actually, no. Be aware that tonight's "colorized" airing of the seldom-seen "I Love Lucy" Christmas outing isn't a standard sitcom episode. It's a clip show -- a resource-saving move in which a series repurposes previously aired scenes as reminiscences/flashbacks, with new wraparound segments.
The holiday half-hour, made in 1956 during the show's original run, resurfaced in 1989 to make a big TV splash in a previous computer-colored effort. With technology having so improved since, it makes sense to recolorize the now high-def-mastered black-and-white original into another tube event -- especially since full-episode color of the musical fantasy "Lucy Goes to Scotland" looked so natural in 2007's complete-series DVD of Lucille Ball's timeless sitcom.
Friday's first scenes might be a shock -- Lucy's "red" hair is tomato orange -- but soon you notice fresh set details, even then-hubby Desi Arnaz's necktie pattern. Lucy's olive green kitchen cements the '50s time frame. You get used to multihued visuals, and then --
It's monochrome again! Color only covers the holiday wraparounds. That's not so bad in a flashback awaiting Little Ricky's birth. But when Lucy visits Ricky's Cuban nightclub, the set has clearly been designed even in black-and-white to evoke a feast of color. Which suddenly feels missing. The CBS hour moves on to full-episode color for Lucy's Italian-movie tale, with its grape-stomping catfight, another multitone natural.
MY SAY Calm down, Lucyheads. Color here isn't heresy. Desi Arnaz was a smart businessman who'd have shot "I Love Lucy" on color film if he'd foreseen its market a decade down the line.
Colorization has improved greatly since its '80s pastel period, and the Italian episode especially uses a sort of faded Technicolor palette to reflect its age.
BOTTOM LINE Forget color. Tonight's high-def clarity should really make us salivate for spring's first "I Love Lucy" Blu-ray release.