Tim Urban, who I don't think we've seen before, with big hair and an earnestness to him, sings David Cook's "Come Back to Me." Wow, where did his deep, world-weary voice come from?! 

It's really different, I like him -- he has the look, and huge likeability. Plus I think he has real depth to him, not a clown, serious about this

Justin Williams, who survived cancer, plays the keyboard, Randy just says, "it's very interesting, that's all I'll say." He's cut; oh well.

Paige Dechausse, Erica Rhodes (dominatrix Barney girl!), Jersey sisters -- all cut. Ah, some of the best characters of the year....

Maddy Curtis, whose brothers have Down Syndrome, sings "Nearness of You," I really like her but the judges aren't so sure. Casey James, who totally looks different than in auditions when he took his shirt off, does some blues guitar; Randy really likes him.

advertisement | advertise on newsday

Casey makes it, not Maddy -- I guess I'd rather it have been the other way around.

PHOTOS: Click here to see contestants and celebrity judges from this year's 'American Idol' audition rounds

FUN: Test your memory -- how many of the winners and top finalists do you remember, from each season of 'American Idol'?

MORE: Read all of our 'American Idol' posts, and put in your two cents