Andrew Garcia, Tim Urban, Aaron Kelly or Siobhan Magnus could all be going home tonight after David Archuleta and Rihanna perform on "American Idol," if you believe our glorious panel of Newsday experts.

Michael Lynche and even Katie Stevens are other candidates for the bottom three, as the competition starts to get tight and even good singers might not get enough support.

In our contest Peggy Lunquist stays in first place, with the same points again as Jonathan McCarthy but a perfect record of picking the person booted off.

Here are all our picks, below. (Scoring system: You get one point for each contestant correctly predicted to be in the bottom three, with an extra point if you pick who went home.)

Peggy Lundquist (3-0, 10 points)
-Andrew Garcia (going home)
-Katie Stevens
-Tim Urban

Jonathan McCarthy (2-1, 10 points)
-Andrew Garcia (going home)
-Michael Lynche
-Tim Urban

Verne Gay (2-1, 8 points)
-Andrew Garcia (going home)
-Aaron Kelly
-Siohban Magnus

Adam Abramson (1-2, 8 points)
-Tim Urban (going home)
-Aaron Kelly
-Andrew Garcia

Jamshid Mousavinezhad (1-2, 8 points)
-Tim Urban (going home)
-Andrew Garcia
-Michael Lynche

Daniel Bubbeo (1-2, 7 points)
-Andrew Garcia (going home)
-Tim Urban
-Siobhan Mangus

advertisement | advertise on newsday

Glenn Gamboa (1-2, 7 points)
-Andrew Garcia (going home)
-Siobhan Magnus
-Katie Stevens

Ronnie Gill (0-3, 6 points)
-Aaron Kelly (going home)
-Andrew Garcia
-Tim Urban

Eileen Fredes (1-1, 4 points)
-Siobhan Magnus (going home)
-Andrew Garcia
-Aaron Kelly

Anne Bratskeir (0-0)
-Aaron Kelly (going home)
-Siobhan Magnus
-Tim Urban

PHOTOS: "American Idol" final round | "Idol" top 12 party with "Glee" stars

REWIND: See the winners and top finalists from each season of "American Idol"

MORE: Read all of our other "American Idol" posts

TALK: Who should be kicked off tonight? Click on "Add a comment" at the bottom of this post, or e-mail me and I'll post it for you.