24-hour diners on Long Island: 12 favorites

+-

Over the past few years, many Long Island diners have switched from 24/7 availability to round-the-clock service on weekends only. Marino Frangomihalos, owner of the Broadway Diner in Hicksville, went over to 24-hour weekends two years ago. During the week, he said, "there was no business."

Despite the late-night midweek slump, some 24/7 diners are holding fast to tradition. "It's a convenience for our regular customers," said Nick Konstantatos, owner of the California Diner in Patchogue. And for Valentino Zarboutis, co-owner of the Massapequa Diner, change isn't even an option. "We will always be open 24 hours," he said.

So, if you're in need of a cheeseburger, short stack or omelet at any hour, here are 10 24-hour diners ready to feed you. And three more that are open round-the-clock on weekends only.

Yesterday's Diner

Yesterday's Diner, New Hyde Park: This diner, convenient
(Credit: Aaron Zebrook)

Yesterday's Diner, New Hyde Park: This diner, convenient to Long Island Jewish Medical Center, serves up burgers, gyros and omelets at all hours.

Banana-stuffed pancakes with strawberries are a favorite at
(Credit: Aaron Zebrook)

Banana-stuffed pancakes with strawberries are a favorite at Yesterday's Diner in New Hyde Park.

Carle Place Diner

Carle Place Diner, Carle Place: Situated near Winthrop-University
(Credit: Aaron Zebrook)

Carle Place Diner, Carle Place: Situated near Winthrop-University Hospital, Roosevelt Field and UPS headquarters, this diner services a workforce that may be on the job around-the-clock. On weekends, says owner Larry Hotzoglou, the crowd is more of a mix of people out having a good time. Most popular items ordered: steak and eggs, burgers, pancakes and omelets.

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISE HERE
The triple-decker roast beef club is a late-night
(Credit: Aaron Zebrook)

The triple-decker roast beef club is a late-night favorite at the Carle Place Diner.

Lantern Diner

Lantern Diner, West Hempstead: Co-owner Lori Zimmerman says
(Credit: Aaron Zebrook)

Lantern Diner, West Hempstead: Co-owner Lori Zimmerman says the diner is hopping late at night Wednesday to Saturday, when it feeds a hungry bar crowd. Other nights are quieter. During snowstorms, a lot of truckers come in. Popular choices include burgers, quesadillas and steak and eggs. Coffee and cappuccino are big, too.

Ribeye steak and eggs are served at the
(Credit: Aaron Zebrook)

Ribeye steak and eggs are served at the Lantern Diner in West Hempstead.

Majestic Diner

Majestic Diner, Westbury: During the week, co-owner Philip
(Credit: Aaron Zebrook)

Majestic Diner, Westbury: During the week, co-owner Philip Bogdos sees a clientele of industrial workers on the overnight shift, as well as delivery people. Weekends, the crowd is younger overall and includes those coming from Nassau Coliseum and NYCB Theatre at Westbury. What they're ordering: pancakes and egg dishes, as well as burgers and turkey club sandwiches.

Ice cream sundaes are a late-night favorite at
(Credit: Aaron Zebrook)

Ice cream sundaes are a late-night favorite at the Majestic Diner on Old Country Road in Westbury.

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISE HERE

Empress Diner

Empress Diner, East Meadow: Here, the late crowd
(Credit: Aaron Zebrook)

Empress Diner, East Meadow: Here, the late crowd includes hospital, bar, county jail, police department, utility and snowplow workers. Says owner Mike Panagatos, "They usually order burger deluxes and omelets. Pancakes, too. We're known for 17 different types. Plain is still the most popular, but at night, we sell a lot of 'Elvis' pancakes made with peanut butter, banana and cinnamon."

(Credit: Aaron Zebrook)

"Green eggs and ham," a late-night favorite at the Empress Diner in East Meadow.

Massapequa Diner

Massapequa Diner, Massapequa: Night-shift workers make up the
(Credit: Aaron Zebrook)

Massapequa Diner, Massapequa: Night-shift workers make up the midweek late crowd, says co-owner Valentino Zarboutis, who adds that weekends are busiest, with an influx of teenagers and college kids. Everyone favors burgers and eggs.

Disco Fries are a late-night favorite at the
(Credit: Aaron Zebrook)

Disco Fries are a late-night favorite at the Massapequa Diner.

Embassy Diner

Embassy Diner, Bethpage: Situated near St. Joseph
(Credit: Aaron Zebrook)

Embassy Diner, Bethpage: Situated near St. Joseph Hospital, this diner offers omelets, Belgian waffles, cheeseburgers and triple-decker sandwiches.

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISE HERE
Stuffed clams are served at the Embassy Diner,
(Credit: Aaron Zebrook)

Stuffed clams are served at the Embassy Diner, open 24 hours in Bethpage.

Carousel Diner

Carousel Diner, West Islip:
(Credit: Aaron Zebrook)

Carousel Diner, West Islip: "Clubbers," overnight workers, and those starting work early (some at airports) make up the late-night crowd here, said co-owner Chris Costea. Slow midweek traffic picks up on Thursday and Friday, especially when college kids are home. Popular choices from the special late-night menu: egg dishes, "loaded" fries, wraps, quesadillas, wings and burgers.

Candlelight Diner

Candlelight Diner, Commack: Co-owner Leo Constantatos says the
(Credit: Heather Walsh)

Candlelight Diner, Commack: Co-owner Leo Constantatos says the place (which shares ownership with the California Diner) starts hopping weekends after 2 a.m., when people come from the bars. After the bars close, at 4:30 a.m., there's another influx of bar employees. And all week long, early- and late-shift workers stop in. During the summer, there's also traffic to and from the Hamptons. What everyone's ordering: egg dishes and burgers.

All kinds of desserts are on display at
(Credit: Aaron Zebrook)

All kinds of desserts are on display at the Candlelight Diner, open 24 hours in Commack.

California Diner

California Diner, Patchogue: Co-owner Nick Konstantatos finds a
(Credit: Heather Walsh)

California Diner, Patchogue: Co-owner Nick Konstantatos finds a large weekend clientele coming from The Emporium, a major night club in Patchogue. Both clubgoers and club workers have an appetite for such items as skirt steak with eggs, eggs Benedict, pancakes and burgers. While late-night business can be slow in winter, it picks up during snowstorms when shovelers and snow-plow drivers stop in. There's also a surge when college students come home for the holidays. Come summer, the diner is a stop at all hours for travelers to and from the Hamptons.

A late-night order of pancakes topped with strawberries,
(Credit: Heather Walsh)

A late-night order of pancakes topped with strawberries, walnuts, butter and syrup is served at The California Diner in Patchogue.

Broadway Diner

Broadway Diner, Hicksville: Instead of a big bar

Broadway Diner, Hicksville: Instead of a big bar crowd, owner Marino Frangomihalos is seeing lots of people coming in after parties and weddings. They're ordering late-night specials such as roast beef on a roll, wings, burgers and plenty of eggs and pancakes. "About 70 percent go with breakfast after 2 a.m.," he said. Open: 24 hours Friday and Saturday; Sunday to Thursday, 6 to 2 a.m.; closed Christmas.

The blackjack burger, rubbed with Cajun spices and
(Credit: Aaron Zebrook)

The blackjack burger, rubbed with Cajun spices and topped with Monterey Jack cheese and grilled onions, at Broadway Diner in Hicksville.

Holbrook Diner

Holbrook Diner, Holbrook: Co-owner George Arahovitis says that
(Credit: Erin Geismar)

Holbrook Diner, Holbrook: Co-owner George Arahovitis says that the late weekend crowd is coming from movie theaters, the Patchogue Theater for the Performing arts, as well as the clubs. They're ordering burgers, sandwiches, panini, wraps, pancakes, French toast and cheese fries drenched in gravy. And lots of coffee. Open: 24 hours Friday and Saturday; Sunday to Thursday, 7 to 1 a.m.; open 7 a.m. to noon on Christmas.

The Holbrook panino features grilled chicken, spinach, portabello
(Credit: Daniel Brennan)

The Holbrook panino features grilled chicken, spinach, portabello mushroom and roasted pepper. It's served with fries at the Holbrook Diner.

Hauppauge Palace Diner

Hauppauge Palace Diner, Hauppauge: Jimmy Gonias, co-owner, said
(Credit: Aaron Zebrook)

Hauppauge Palace Diner, Hauppauge: Jimmy Gonias, co-owner, said the diner changed to 24 hours on weekends only about a year ago due to the closure of two major local bars. Customers of a couple of bars in Smithtown, plus those traveling to and from Manhattan, make up the late weekend clientele. They're ordering burgers and eggs, as well as appetizers, such as mozzarella sticks, Buffalo wings and quesadillas. Open: 24 hours Friday and Saturday; Sunday to Thursday, 6 to 2 a.m.

Enter your email address to subscribe to the Feed Me newsletter

Related Media

Thomas's Ham N Eggery in Carle Place and LI eateries that have lasted 20-plus years The Cheesesteak at Industry Standard Bar in Greenport 40 amazing sandwiches to try on LI Del Frisco's Grille in Huntington Station and more 55 great burgers to try on Long Island

Comments

Newsday.com now uses Facebook for our comment boards. Please read our guidelines and connect your Facebook account to comment.

Sorry to interrupt...

Your first 5 are free

Access to Newsday is free for Optimum customers.

Please enjoy 5 complimentary views to articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.

LOGIN SUBSCRIBE