Best steaks on Long Island

Tellers offers a signature rib eye of USDA

(Credit: Doug Young)

Whether you're craving a giant porterhouse or a manageable filet mignon, a juicy rib eye or a surf-and-turf entree, these restaurants provide stellar, reliable options.

  • Critic rating 2
    On the left a 24 oz prime dry

    21 Main $$$ | Steak 21 Montauk Highway West Sayville Orderly and unpretentious, 21 Main serves an excellent T-bone steak for two, a 40-oz. slab with an au poivre bite and Gorgonzola cheese for just enough excess. It's grand. Also enjoyable in the conservatively appointed dining room are a heroic bone-in ribeye, weighing in at 32 ounces; a juicy sirloin; sliced hanger steak with sauteed onions and mushrooms; and a noteworthy filet mignon with a garlic-herb demi-glace.

  • Critic rating 3
    Inside Blackstone Steakhouse in Melville.

    Blackstone Steakhouse $$$$ | American, Steak, Japanese, Seafood, Sushi 10 Pinelawn Rd. Melville In a stone-and-wood style space suggesting what might happen if Frank Lloyd Wright and Disney partnered to produce a compact national park lodge, Blackstone offers up first-class cuts of beef: a juicy rib steak, hefty porterhouse and fibrous, salt-edged sirloin. The steaks are offered with five sauces, including a neoclassic bearnaise.

  • Critic rating 3
    Bryant & Cooper steakhouse in Roslyn

    Bryant & Cooper $$$ | American, Steak 2 Middle Neck Rd. Roslyn Bryant & Cooper ranks among the top all-around Long Island steakhouses, straightforward and recommended for porterhouse and sirloin, filet mignon and ribeye. Also: very good shellfish, vegetables and a linguine with white clam sauce to make tricolor-waving competitors jealous.

  • Burton & Doyle is a fancy steakhouse that

    Burton & Doyle $$$ | Seafood, Steak, New American, Sushi, Restaurant 661 Northern Blvd. Great Neck A distinctive, luxe spot, slide into one of their comfortable, rounded booths and dig into a carnivore's favorite: the porterhouse (for one or two), a juicy, crusty slab of beef. The T-bone for one gives you an only slightly smaller, full-flavored variation on the theme, and the filet mignon is very thick and very good.

  • Critic rating 2
    Shallot butter delivers the shine to an excellent,

    The Capital Grille $$$$ | Seafood, Chain restaurants, Steak 630 Old Country Rd. Garden City The steaks at this upscale, national chain are dependably very good. Shallot butter delivers the shine to an excellent, bone-in, Kona coffee-crusted, dry-aged sirloin; very tender, sliced filet mignon benefits from a bed of cipollini onions and wild mushrooms.

  • Critic rating 2
    Franks Steak Jericho

    Frank's Steaks (Jericho) $$$ | American, Steak 4 Jericho Tpke. Jericho An enjoyable restaurant for well-prepared, unadorned American food, the emphasis is on juicy beef. With a setting matching the simplicity of the menu, the best options are the porterhouse steak for two, T-bone for one, bone-in strip steak and Romanian skirt steak.

  • Critic rating 2
    Steak dinner with grilled onions, mashed potatoes and

    Frank's Steaks (Rockville Centre) $$$ | Steak 54 Lincoln Ave. Rockville Centre The restaurant has built a reputation of sorts for its marinated Romanian skirt steak, which is juicy and sweet. Better are the porterhouse for two, the peppercorn-crusted ribeye and the garlicky ribeye. There's husky prime rib too,

  • Critic rating 2.5
    George Martin's Strip Steak in Great River offers

    George Martin's Strip Steak $$$ | Steak, American 60 River Rd. Great River In its first Suffolk foray, the George Martin Group has established a prime site. The juicy porterhouse steak for two and the lush filet mignon lead the steaks.

  • Critic rating 3
    Bone-in-rib steak is served at Insignia Prime Steak

    Insignia $$$$ | Sushi, American, Steak 610 Nesconset Highway, Smithtown For restaurateur-as-impresario Anthony Scotto, this brassy palace of protein completes a trifecta. (He also owns Rare650 in Syosset and Blackstone Steakhouse in Melville.) A dry-aged Kansas City strip steak stands out, despite its gilding of truffled foie-gras butter. Also notable are the porterhouse for two or more; fist-size cut of filet mignon; Wagyu steaks, with more marbling than a Carrara quarry; and the 16-ounce Australian ribeye, for $89.

Enter your email address to subscribe to the Feed Me newsletter


Newsday.com now uses Facebook for our comment boards. Please read our guidelines and connect your Facebook account to comment.

By using this site, you agree to our Privacy policy.

Sorry to interrupt...

Your first 5 are free

Access to Newsday is free for Optimum customers.

Please enjoy 5 complimentary views to articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.