Bread & Butter Bistro review

+ -
Bread & Butter Bistro's roasted French-cut chicken breast Bread & Butter Bistro's roasted French-cut chicken breast is full of flavor. (May 11, 2013) Photo Credit: Heather Walsh

advertisement | advertise on newsday

Location info

Location: 1730 N Ocean Ave. Holtsville, NY 11742

User rating:

Description: Burgers are a night owl's dream at this pub-style restaurant that's attached to the Ramada ... More »

It's 3 a.m. on a Saturday night, and you're nursing a powerful yen for a burger. If life has brought you to Exit 63 on the LIE, then you're in luck. Attached to the Ramada Plaza Long Island is a handsome pub that's open nearly round the clock on weekends.

At

Bread & Butter Bistro , burgers are a night owl's dream. If only everything on chef Piers Stringer's menu were of the same caliber. A black cracked pepper-crusted smoked Gouda gratin-topped ground beef patty is a juicy, smoky knockout with ideal bun-to-burger ratio. Yet, fries sharing the plate are the humdrum, frozen variety. Unevenness seems the rule.

Most meals will start with a basket of house-baked bread; the thick slices are dry and can't be rescued by the accompanying bacon jalapeƱo and garlic herb butters. No problems with a bowl of chicken-vegetable soup loaded with colorful vegetables. Fine, too, is an apple-braised, pulled-pork taco. Mac and cheese -- three cheeses, actually -- has been cooked to a soft, bland paste. An unconventional bacon-topped Caesar salad is supposed to sport a soft poached egg, but that ingredient is missing. Still, it's an eminently likable salad.

The ingredient lacking in a grilled chicken pesto sandwich is verve. And vegetable-studded pasta with garlic and oil seems devoid of both garlic and oil; it's better after being sent back for seasoning and moisture. Another time, a teriyaki-glazed salmon fillet comes out seriously overcooked and is returned, too. A chef -- not Stringer -- brings its over-salty replacement, causing discomfort by remarking that the first one had been perfect. On the other hand, a grilled skirt steak is juicy and full of flavor, as is a roasted French-cut chicken breast.

To understand what Stringer is capable of, order dessert. Warm zeppole with house-made vanilla ice cream is worth dieting all week for. So, too, a fudgy, pure-tasting brownie sundae.

Given the restaurant's name, it seems a wake-up call is needed for a crew that pre-cuts, reheats and, therefore, undermines the bread that's baked fresh daily. And while late hours and a music scene may pull in a weekend crowd, it would take nothing more -- or less -- than TLC to make this a true bread and butter bistro.

Subscribe to our newsletter for restaurant recommendations, recipes and more.

Comments

Newsday.com now uses Facebook for our comment boards. Please read our guidelines and connect your Facebook account to comment.

You also may be interested in: