Casa Rustica

175 W. Main St. Smithtown, NY 631-265-9265

Casa Rustica restaurant in Smithtown, a haven for

(Credit: Joseph D. Sullivan)

Submit a photo »
View map

Critic rating: 3

User rating:
(19) Click to rate
Type: Italian Special features: Lunch, Business lunch, Romantic, Parties and groups, Kid friendly Price range:

$$$ (Expensive)


Compelling, full-flavored, regional Italian cooking and very attentive service define Casa Rustica, a local star for more than two decades, now under Fermin Martinez. The attractive, remodeled dining room is not so rustic, anymore. Whole fish cooked in salt crust, scallops with chickpea salad, veal chop Valdostana, bistecca alla Fiorentina, venison chop with berries, seafood salad, ravioli in pink sauce, agnolotti alla Piemontese, penne Bolognese, all risotti, cold antipasti are great, as are all pastries.


Dinner every day. Lunch, Monday to Friday.



Credit cards:



One-level dining area.

Party size:

Party rooms


Newsday.com now uses Facebook for our comment boards. Please read our guidelines and connect your Facebook account to comment.