GM Burger Bar, first bites

The "Juicy Lucy" at GM Burger Bar in The "Juicy Lucy" at GM Burger Bar in Rockville Centre. (Aug., 2013) Photo Credit: Newsday Joan Reminick

advertisement | advertise on newsday

Feed Me

The dish on Long Island's restaurant and food scene.

A recent dinner at the new GM Burger Bar in Rockville Centre proved something of a mixed experience.

Looks here isnt an issue. The place is ruggedly handsome, in the manner of all the George Martin Group restaurants. And it was hopping the night I went. Lines out the door as well as sidewalk dining.

advertisement | advertise on newsday

Here, the crew seemed more intent on getting people in and than on getting things right. A Frenchy burger, which a companion  requested medium-rare, arrived somewhere between medium and well-done. The waiter pointed out there was at least a little bit of pink at the center and didnt offer to have it redone. Topped with onions caramelized in sherry, Gruyere and mozzarella, it came with onion-beef jus on the side. Lots of flavor  and moisture everywhere, except the actual burger. And the sourdough roll it was served on was so big and thick, it had to be abandoned for knife and fork. Cottage fries on the side were better than an order of hand-cut shoestring fries, which lacked crispness as well as flavor. Great pickles on the side. Pretty good chili lime slaw.

A specialty here is the Juicy Lucy burger ($14.95), stuffed with bacon and three cheeses, basted with Worcestershire and served on a brioche roll. A panoply of bold flavors. Still, you cant get it medium-rare, since, we were told, the cheese wouldnt be hot enough to melt. Not bad but far from juicy. Hard to tell which was drier the "Pilgrim" turkey burger or the multigrain roll it was served on.

Best was a simple 5-ounce burger, done to temperature and served on a soft hamburger bun you might actually be able to get your mouth around.

GM Burger Bar is at 209 N. Long Beach Rd., Rockville Centre; 516-208-6100,

Subscribe to our newsletter for restaurant recommendations, recipes and more.

You also may be interested in: