Open: Puglia's City Cafe in Garden City

The exterior of Puglia of Little Italy in The exterior of Puglia of Little Italy in East Meadow. Photo Credit: AJ Imaging Photo

advertisement | advertise on newsday

Feed Me

The dish on Long Island's restaurant and food scene.

Anyone expecting a sequel to East Meadow's Puglia of Little Italy at Puglia's City Cafe is in for a surprise.

The new spot is that time-capsule establishment, a supper club, which, the business card alerts you, covers "Fine Dining & Dancing."  It's all taking place on the former site of City Cafe and currently offers a pared-down menu that's not all Italian. But the main draw: live entertainment, last night with a singer devoted to songs along the lines of  "The Shadow of Your Smile" and  "More." There's a small dance floor and a big bar.

If you do come here to eat, try arancini, a tasty rice ball that will evoke memories of the two-star East Meadow restaurant. The stuffed artichoke also is respectable. But you can skip the chicken alla Joe, a thick cutlet, routinely Francaise, in favor of linguine with clam sauce. The only finfish: tilapia. A terse sushi menu also is available. They're likely to lead you the filet mignon and the rib-eye steak.

You can conclude with very good, fill-your-own cannoli -- three mini-shells accompanied by a serving of sweet ricotta cream with chocolate chips.

On the calendar so far: every Tuesday at 8 p.m. Body & Soul with DJ Johnny V; every Wednesday, singer Johnny Avino; every Thursday,  Johnny Fusco. Tomorrow night, it's East Coast; Saturday night Uppercut; and Friday, Oct. 1, Kathy & the Revivals.

If you're really planning ahead, on Nov. 18, Puglia's City Cafe will host "The Italian Chick Show," a dinner and comedy production for $49 per person plus tax and tip. To be at the bar: $20, which includes one drink.

Puglia's City Cafe, 987 Stewart Ave., Garden City; 516-222-1421.

advertisement | advertise on newsday

Puglia of Little Italy in East Meadow ... still recommended

Subscribe to the Feed Me Newsletter for the latest restaurant news, recipes and recommendations.

You also may be interested in: