+-

Harbor Crab Co.

116 Division St. Patchogue, NY 631-687-2722

A waiter delivers an order of lobster, sea

(Credit: Newsday File / Bill Davis )

Submit a photo »
User rating:
3
(3) Click to rate
Type: Seafood, Restaurant Special features: Water views, Outdoor Seating Price range: $$$ (Expensive) Description:

The vibe was more Key West than Patchogue: faux palm trees at the entrance, brightly painted ceramic and papier-mache tropical fish on the walls and Jimmy Buffett tunes on the sound system. Harbor Crab Co. was hopping, even on a weeknight, when we waited half an hour for a table on the floating deck overlooking an inlet of the Patchogue River.

It was dusk when we began eating. A short distance away, a double-decker LIRR train rolled past on an overpass; the deck shook briefly. A server came by offering insect repellent. We refused, but after a few swats, requested a spray bottle. One of the restaurant's owners brought it over, staying to chat a while.

"What's the she crab soup like?" we asked.

"It's creamy," he said. "A bisque. I'll bring you a sample."

That sample turned out to be a sweet and briny bowlful whose consistency was satiny, much lighter than a bisque. Another suggestion of his, crab cakes, didn't fare so well. They were crisp on the outside with a nice flavor, but the interior texture mimicked mashed potatoes. A surprise hit was the restaurant's signature appetizer of seafood "skins": potato shells filled with a melange of creamed shrimp, scallops and crab meat, topped with melted Cheddar -- one of those rare dishes that taste lots better than it sounds.

It was during a long lull between courses that we felt a few fine droplets of water. "It's nothing," our waitress said. Minutes later, we -- along with everyone else on the deck -- bolted indoors, barely escaping a downpour.

From our table near a bamboo wall, we admired the clever tropical decorations around us. We were happy with what was on our plates, as well. My husband's Southwest-style fried catfish was crisp, greaseless, deftly spiced. I was pleased with a shrimp platter consisting of large shellfish sauteed, New Orleans style, with tasso ham, celery, garlic and lemon in an herbal wine sauce. Best of all was a dish called Harbor seafood supreme, a spirited saute of shrimp, scallops, mussels, clams and crab meat in a garlicky lemon white-wine sauce over al dente bow-tie pasta.

Our waitress confessed that none of the desserts had been made on premises. Her favorite, she said, was a slab of Junior's cheesecake. It was simple and satisfying, a fitting conclusion to a pleasurable evening.  --Joan Reminick (8/29/07)

If you want to dock and dine, there are 10 slips and no dockage fee at Buoy 34 in the Patchogue River.

Hours: Lunch, Monday to Saturday, 11:30 a.m. to 4 p.m.; dinner, 4 to 10 p.m., Monday to Thursday, Friday and Saturday, 4 to 11 p.m., Sunday, noon to 9 p.m.
A waiter delivers an order of lobster, sea

A waiter delivers an order of lobster, sea scallop scampi and seafood supreme at Harbor Crab in Patchogue. (Credit: Newsday File / Bill Davis )

The vibe was more Key West than Patchogue: faux palm trees at the entrance, brightly painted ceramic and papier-mache tropical fish on the walls and Jimmy Buffett tunes on the sound system. Harbor Crab Co. was hopping, even on a weeknight, when we waited half an hour for a table on the floating deck overlooking an inlet of the Patchogue River. It was dusk when we began eating. A short distance away, a double-decker LIRR train rolled past on an overpass; the deck shook briefly. A server came by offering insect repellent. We refused, but after a few swats, requested a spray bottle. One of the restaurant's owners brought it over, staying to chat a while. "What's the she crab soup like?" we asked. "It's creamy," he said. "A bisque. I'll bring you a sample." That sample turned out to be a sweet and briny bowlful whose consistency was satiny, much lighter than a bisque. Another suggestion of his, crab cakes, didn't fare so well. They were crisp on the outside with a nice flavor, but the interior texture mimicked mashed potatoes. A surprise hit was the restaurant's signature appetizer of seafood "skins": potato shells filled with a melange of creamed shrimp, scallops and crab meat, topped with melted Cheddar -- one of those rare dishes that taste lots better than it sounds. It was during a long lull between courses that we felt a few fine droplets of water. "It's nothing," our waitress said. Minutes later, we -- along with everyone else on the deck -- bolted indoors, barely escaping a downpour. From our table near a bamboo wall, we admired the clever tropical decorations around us. We were happy with what was on our plates, as well. My husband's Southwest-style fried catfish was crisp, greaseless, deftly spiced. I was pleased with a shrimp platter consisting of large shellfish sauteed, New Orleans style, with tasso ham, celery, garlic and lemon in an herbal wine sauce. Best of all was a dish called Harbor seafood supreme, a spirited saute of shrimp, scallops, mussels, clams and crab meat in a garlicky lemon white-wine sauce over al dente bow-tie pasta. Our waitress confessed that none of the desserts had been made on premises. Her favorite, she said, was a slab of Junior's cheesecake. It was simple and satisfying, a fitting conclusion to a pleasurable evening. --Joan Reminick (8/29/07) If you want to dock and dine, there are 10 slips and no dockage fee at Buoy 34 in the Patchogue River. 

Comments

Newsday.com now uses Facebook for our comment boards. Please read our guidelines and connect your Facebook account to comment.