Jimmy Hays Steakhouse

+ -

advertisement | advertise on newsday

Jimmy Hays calls itself a steak house, and there's no arguing with the prime beef, dry-aged on the premises. Beyond the 17-ounce New York strip, filet mignon (which can also be had au poivre), porterhouse and chateaubriand for two, there are big, fat pork chops and double-cut lamb chops from American sheep.


Under chef Richard Burns, lobsters, all of them at least two pounds, can be had steamed, broiled and a la Jimmy (sauteed with cognac, lemon and garlic). Culinary warhorses thermidor and a l'Americain appear regularly as specials. There's plenty of other seafood on the menu.


Speaking of appetizers, no first-time diner should skip the way-over-the-top roasted garlic bread drenched in Gorgonzola sauce, a dish almost comically delicious.

The side salad that comes with dinner is a desultory affair of nothing-special lettuce and seasonless tomatoes, but most of the other sides are terrific, especially the onion rings and the potato dishes: French fries, matchsticks, hash browns, home fries, Lyonnaise (pan-fried with onions), O'Brien (sauteed with peppers and onions), au gratin (baked with cream and topped with cheese) and cottage fries, a crispy potato galette that rests underneath (and soaks up the juices from) the special rack of lamb.

advertisement | advertise on newsday


Jimmy Hays is an attractive, sprawling place with a comfortable bar and multiple bustling dining rooms. Everything runs like clockwork, and while it's not inexpensive (entrees range from $28 to $46), it always feels like a good value.

Reviewed by Erica Marcus 

Subscribe to our newsletter for restaurant recommendations, recipes and more.


Newsday.com now uses Facebook for our comment boards. Please read our guidelines and connect your Facebook account to comment.

You also may be interested in: