Memorable restaurants for seafood on LI


The "bottomless mussel pot" is a must-have at Reel in East Rockaway. Photo Credit: Nicole Horton

advertisement | advertise on newsday

Good seafood restaurants are surprisingly few in Nassau and Suffolk. Here are four dependable ones.

WILDFISH, 507 Guy Lombardo Blvd., Freeport; 516-442-0565

This warm-weather, Freeport spot offers a waterside setting to complement the fish and shellfish. Try tuna crudo accented with yuzu, scallop seviche, the lobster-themed Cobb salad, clams oreganata, fish-and-chips made with cod, and kung pao-style calamari.

JACK HALYARDS, 60 South St., Oyster Bay; 516-922-2999

Although not strictly a seafood house, Jack Halyards excels with grilled swordfish, calamari fired up with hot cherry peppers and tomato sauce, ahi tuna tartare nachos, kung pao-style shrimp, a Maryland crabcake, and oven-roasted Chatham cod with white clam sauce. 

SEA LEVELS, 391 N. Windsor Ave., Brightwaters; 631-665-8300

advertisement | advertise on newsday

A staple in Brightwaters, Sea Levels' fare includes Long Island clam-and-corn chowder, Blue Point oysters and littleneck clams, fried calamari, shrimp cocktail, sesame-crusted tuna with warm soba noodle salad, and crabmeat-crusted salmon.

REEL, 1 Main St., East Rockaway; 516-341-7222

Chef Adam Goldgell, who appeared on the Food Network's "Restaurant Express," makes a memorable appetizer dubbed "oysters 2 ways," one a cream-and-Pernod stew with shellfish in an espresso cup; the other, crisp, cornmeal-crusted oysters. Also notable: mussel pots, beer-battered fish-and-chips, pan-sauteed monkfish Caribbean-style.

Subscribe to our newsletter for restaurant recommendations, recipes and more.

Comments now uses Facebook for our comment boards. Please read our guidelines and connect your Facebook account to comment.

You also may be interested in: