Most romantic restaurants on Long Island

Date night.

(Credit: iStock)

There are as many ways to define a romantic restaurant as there are those looking for one. Marcello and Sophia? Cary and Grace? Or maybe Sid and Nancy? You think it's easy? That said, here are a range of romantic restaurants recommended by our critics. And to really impress your amour, the best advice is to reserve early. --Compiled by Peter M. Gianotti, Joan Reminick and Erica Marcus

  • Critic rating 3
    The exterior of The 1770 House in East

    The 1770 House $$$$ | B&B and Inn, New American, Hotel Motel 143 Main St. East Hampton What started as a home is now a landmark. The seamless service and the sensibility ...

  • The American Hotel $$$$ | Hotel Motel, American, French 49 Main St. Sag Harbor The American Hotel, which has eight guest rooms, is a local landmark. It's known for ...

  • Critic rating 2.5
    Customers lunch at Aperitif, a French bistro in

    Aperitif $$$ | French 252 Sunrise Hwy. Rockville Centre This updated bistro, warm and welcoming, has Parisian flair to spare. ...

  • Critic rating 2.5
    Bistro 25 in Sayville has a new, sleek

    Bistro 25 $$ | New American 45 Foster Ave. Sayville A "recession friendly" place to eat, where the menu includes a small plate of truffled ...

  • Critic rating 2
    Inside Brasserie Cassis in Plainview.

    Brasserie Cassis $$$ | Lounge, Bistros - Brasseries, French 387 S. Oyster Bay Rd. Plainview Vintage ads, tiled floors and a full bar offer a full dining opportunity, with a ...

  • Critic rating 1.5
    Espana restaurant serves cuisine from Spain and is

    Espana Tapas and Wine Bar $$ | European, Small plates, Spanish, Tapas (small plates) 655 Middle Country Rd. St. James An aura of authenticity informs this charming Spanish tapas and wine bar. Start with a ...

  • Critic rating 2.5
    The Frankly Thai restaurant is at 959 Hempstead

    Frankly Thai $$ | Restaurant, Thai, Vegetarian 959 Hempstead Tpke. Franklin Square Our reviewer thinks Frankly Thai in Franklin Square is, frankly, fine. ...

  • Critic rating 1.5
    Patrons eat on the second floor of Harbor

    Harbor Mist $$$ | American, Seafood 105 Harbor Rd. Cold Spring Harbor An easygoing eatery that steers a safe course through familiar American and Continental favorites, allowing ...

  • Critic rating 3
    Hendrick's Tavern in Roslyn features several dining areas,

    Hendrick's Tavern $$$$ | New American 1305 Old Northern Blvd. Roslyn Brothers George and Gillis Poll brothers have transformed what was the creaking George Washington Manor ...

  • The Jamesport Manor Inn is tucked away on

    Jamesport Manor Inn $$$ | New American 370 Manor Lane Jamesport Rebuilt and renewed, the Jamesport Manor Inn is an ideal North Fork stop year-round. ...

Feed Me


Newsday.com now uses Facebook for our comment boards. Please read our guidelines and connect your Facebook account to comment.