Top 10 pasta dishes on LI

Long Islanders love their pasta!

(Credit: iStock)

Restaurant critic Peter M. Gianotti has eaten more than his share of pasta at Long Island restaurants, and, naturally, some is better than others. Here are his 10 favorites.

  • Critic rating 3
    Casa Rustica restaurant in Smithtown, a haven for

    Casa Rustica $$$ | Italian 175 W. Main St. Smithtown Pasta con sarde: Sicilian reverie with bucatini, sardines, fennel, pignoli, more.

  • Critic rating 2.5
    Customers at Verace in Islip can eat on

    Verace $$$ | Pasta, Pizza, Italian 599 Main St. Islip Spaghetti alla carbonara: the local Roman holiday.

  • Critic rating 3.5
    Try the fine butternut-squash raviolo finished with butter,

    Trattoria Diane $$$ | Italian 21 Bryant Ave. Roslyn Bucatini all'Amatriciana: full-flavored regional favorite from The Marches.

  • Critic rating 4
    Stresa in Manhasset

    Stresa $$$ | Italian 1524 Northern Blvd. Manhasset Bigoli alla Latina: pancetta, cabbage, tomatoes, pecorino, pleasure.

  • Critic rating 2
    Mamma Lombardi's in Holbrook

    Mamma Lombardi's $$$ | Italian-American, Italian, Pasta 400 Furrows Rd. Holbrook Penne arrabbiata: tomatoes, garlic, hot red pepper, an "angry" sauce to make you smile.

  • Critic rating 3

    Pentimento $$$ | Italian, Restaurant 93 Main St. Stony Brook Spinach-and-ricotta gnocchi in pork-and-fennel ragu: North and South in harmony.

  • Critic rating 3
    Diners linger over their suppers at Almond restaurant

    Almond $$$ | Bistros - Brasseries, French, Karaoke and Open jams 1 Ocean Rd. Bridgehampton Linguine with clams: in an American-style bistro, an unexpected treat.

  • Critic rating 3.5
    Luigi Q in Hicksville

    Luigi Q $$ | Italian 400A S. Oyster Bay Rd. Hicksville Shrimp-stuffed paccheri: a relative of rigatoni that's finished in light tomato sauce.

  • Critic rating 2.5
    Jonathan's Ristorante, at 15 Wall St., has been

    Jonathan's $$$ | Italian 15 Wall St. Huntington Strozzapreti alla Bolognese: "priest stranglers," similar to extra-long cavatelli, in meat sauce.

  • King Umberto in Elmont

    King Umberto $$ | Pizza, Italian, Pasta 1343 Hempstead Tpke. Elmont Cavatelli with braised short ribs: sweet peas, ricotta and pomodoro sauce complete it.

Subscribe to our newsletter for restaurant recommendations, recipes and more.


Newsday.com now uses Facebook for our comment boards. Please read our guidelines and connect your Facebook account to comment.