MTA payroll tax constitutional, rules appellate court

The Broadway Lafayette subway station in Manhattan. (Sept.

The Broadway Lafayette subway station in Manhattan. (Sept. 24, 2012) Photo Credit: Anthony Lanzilote

advertisement | advertise on newsday

An appellate court ruled Wednesday that the MTA payroll tax is constitutional, reversing a lower court judge who ruled for Nassau County in a lawsuit seeking abolition of the tax.

Nassau sued the Metropolitan Transportation Authority in 2010, maintaining that the tax violated the state constitution because it changed the tax policies of individual municipalities for a purpose that did not benefit the entire state. In his August ruling, State Supreme Court Justice R. Bruce Cozzens Jr. agreed.

But the Appellate Division overturned Cozzens' decision Wednesday, saying the authority's law governing employer taxes "provides a funding source for the preservation, operation and improvement of essential transit and transportation services" in the entire MTA region. The tax, therefore, "serves a substantial state concern," the ruling said.

"We maintain the tax is overburdensome and just plain unfair," Nassau County Executive Edward Mangano said in a statement.

The tax was created in 2009 as part of a state bailout of the MTA as it faced a nearly $2 billion budget gap. The tax charges large employers in the MTA region 34 cents for every $100 of payroll, while small business owners pay lower rates.

The tax generates about $1.2 billion in annual revenue for the MTA, the largest public transportation provider in North America. MTA spokesman Aaron Donovan called the system "the backbone of the region's economy" and said he was pleased with the appellate court's decision.

advertisement | advertise on newsday

"Removal of the tax's revenues would have had a catastrophic impact on the region's 8.5 million daily transit riders," Donovan said in a statement.

The appellate ruling mirrored several others on lawsuits filed by various suburban municipalities looking to abolish the tax, including the towns of Huntington, Brookhaven, Southold and Southampton.

Nassau filed its suit while battling the MTA on how to finance its bus system, which the MTA ran for 37 years, until 2012.


Following Cozzens' ruling, the MTA warned that losing the tax could result in massive service cuts, including on the Long Island Rail Road, that would dwarf any seen previously.

"We wouldn't just be facing cutting weekend service on the West Hempstead Branch. We'd possibly face cutting off the West Hempstead Branch," William Henderson, executive director of the MTA's Permanent Citizens Advisory Committee, said Wednesday. "The MTA needs that money."

With Robert Brodsky

The best of Newsday every day in your inbox. Get the Newsday Now newsletter!

Comments now uses Facebook for our comment boards. Please read our guidelines and connect your Facebook account to comment.

You also may be interested in: