Spin Cycle

News, views and commentary on Long Island, state and national politics.

The talk of the courthouse in Mineola has been that Justice Edward W. McCarty of state Supreme Court, a former prosecutor, would like to be district attorney one day.


So it took the courthouse gossips by surprise when he was nominated recently by the GOP  to run for surrogate — the judgeship with the powers to dole out legal work to lawyers.


McCarthy spent 14 years as an assistant district attorney in Mineola before becoming a District Court judge in 1985, and a state Supreme Court justice in 1992.

advertisement | advertise on newsday


His competition is incumbent Surrogate John Riordan, the first Democrat to hold the position post-World War II. He got elected in 2000 when county financial troubles were weakening the Republican’s iron grip on county government.