Prosecutors say Pappias, a manager at his family's Northport luncheonette, fled after striking Schultz, 49, of Massapequa Park, who was on a paving crew working on Route 25A near Sunken Meadow Parkway.
Judge Martin Efman ordered him held on $50,000 cash bail. Pappias is to return to court Feb. 16.
"If he did this, he did a terrible thing," Naiburg said in court. If convicted, Pappias faces a maximum sentence of 2 1/3 to 7 years in prison.
Assistant District Attorney Nicholas Santomartino said in court that Pappias ordered parts online after the incident and repaired damage to his black 1996 Chevrolet Tahoe.
Police say they linked the Tahoe to vehicle detritus left at the crash scene. That, combined with tips called in to a police hotline, led them to Pappias, police and prosecutors said.
Pappias gave police a five-page statement in which he acknowledged that he may have hit Schultz, prosecutors said. His sister and employer, who were in court, declined to speak to reporters.
Naiburg said Pappias is separated from his wife and has four children, ages 11 to 18.
John Duffy III, who said he was Schultz's cousin, said the family was grateful to authorities for the arrest and prosecution.
You also may be interested in:
More coverageNorthport man charged in fatal hit-and-run
A dragnet of thousands of vehicles -- winnowed down by the crime lab, anonymous tipsMom: Hit-run suspect was troubled Teen bike rider critical after Bay Shore car crash
A 15-year-old bicyclist was critically injured when he was struck by a car Tuesday afternoon