Cheap eats on Long Island

Umberto's vibrant shrimp fra diavolo is served with

(Credit: Nancy Borowick)

Big flavors don't have to cost big bucks.

Anyone who tells you otherwise doesn’t know beans about Long Island restaurants. From Cedarhurst to Montauk, you can score culinary coups for under $30 a person. 

How does slow-smoked barbecued ribs with mac and cheese sound at a BBQ joint? Or fresh pasta with wild mushrooms and truffle oil at a gastro pub? Sparkling sashimi at a homey Japanese storefront?

In the mood for Thai red curry with beef? Shrimp oreganata? Succulent copper-skinned rotisserie chicken at a Colombian cantina?

Let this restaurant guide point the way to whatever you crave, with a new restaurant added each week.
— Compiled reviews by Joan Reminick

  • User rating 3
    Crab cake with black bean salsa with chili

    Barrique Kitchen & Wine Bar $$ | Eclectic, Fusion, Small plates 69 Deer Park Ave. Babylon ...

  • Critic rating 2.5
    BBD's -- that stands for Beer Burgers Desserts

    BBD’s $$ | Beer, Burgers, Dessert 49 Rte. 25A Rocky Point BBD’s (which stands for Beers, Burgers, Desserts) is in a category of its own when ...

  • Critic rating 2.5
    Biscuits & Barbeque is located in an old

    Biscuits & Barbeque $$ | Cajun-Creole, Barbecue 106 E 2nd St. Mineola Secreted away in an industrial section of Mineola is a 1940s vintage railroad-car diner. In ...

  • Critic rating 2.5
    Bistro 25 in Sayville has a new, sleek

    Bistro 25 $$ | New American 45 Foster Ave. Sayville A "recession friendly" place to eat, where the menu includes a small plate of truffled ...

  • Critic rating 2.5
    At the Bluepoint Bar & Grill in Blue

    Bluepoint Bar & Grill $$ | Pub, American, New American 154 Montauk Hwy. Blue Point Bluepoint Bar & Grill is the kind of go-to restaurant that today's economy demands. ...

  • Critic rating 2
    Chef Bobby Flay at his new burger joint,

    Bobby's Burger Palace $ | Burgers, Chain restaurants 355 Smith Haven Mall Lake Grove Celebrity chef Bobby Flay is usually better known for his work on TV cooking shows ...

  • Critic rating 2
    Bonefish Grill has two branches on Long Island:

    Bonefish Grill $$ | Restaurant, Seafood, Chain restaurants 472 Smith Haven Mall Lake Grove Long Island's two new Bonefish Gril restaurants may win you over with their tasteful good ...

  • Critic rating 2
    Bostwick's Chowder House is a new seafood restaurant

    Bostwick's Chowder House $$ | Seafood, Raw bar 277 Pantigo Rd. East Hampton At this uber-casual Hamptons fish house, you might spot a movie or TV star at ...

  • Critic rating 3
    Lamb Chops Wu Style prepared by chef-owner Kent

    The Brass Rail $$ | American, Pub, Burgers, Kids 107 Forest Ave. Locust Valley At The Brass Rail, food, mood and prices are all about comfort. ...

  • Critic rating 1
    The pub-style Bread & Butter Bistro is attached

    Bread & Butter Bistro $$ | Lounge, Pub, Sports bar, American, Burgers 1730 N Ocean Ave. Holtsville Burgers are a night owl's dream at this pub-style restaurant that's attached to the ...

advertisement | advertise on newsday


advertisement | advertise on newsday