'Wall' of concrete removed from Oakdale creek

Department of Environmental Conservation officials work on removing

Department of Environmental Conservation officials work on removing an illegal wall of concrete bags that were placed in the water behind a home in Oakdale owned by Anthony Segreto, who placed the bags in the water. Photo Credit: James Carbone

advertisement | advertise on newsday

State Department of Environmental Conservation officials Wednesday removed 150 bags of concrete that the agency said had been illegally stacked in an Oakdale creek that leads into Great South Bay.

The "wall" of bags was taken out of water adjacent to property owned by Anthony Segreto, 69, of Blue Point Road.

If not removed by DEC, "it was likely that the wall would have remained in the creek for the foreseeable future," agency spokeswoman Lisa King said in a statement. If left in place, the concrete could reduce habitat for vegetation, shellfish and invertebrates and make the area more stagnant, increasing the chances of mosquito breeding, officials have said.

Segreto, DEC and Islip Town officials have been embroiled in lawsuits since 2007 over ownership of the property and wetlands regulations.

DEC officials said Segreto built on and filled wetland areas without permits. Earlier this month, the attorney general's office won a restraining order in state supreme court barring him from construction activity.

Segreto maintains that the wetland area of his property is man-made and that allowing it to expand or flood amounts to unlawful taking of property.

advertisement | advertise on newsday

Early Wednesday he unsuccessfully attempted to get a restraining order in federal court prohibiting removal of the concrete, which he said he did not place on the property.

The DEC "should not be on my property," Segreto said Wednesday. "They are taking actions to make a waterway on my land, which is not a waterway. It's my land."

Islip Town Attorney Robert Cicale said, "The town's position is he doesn't have a viable case."

The best of Newsday every day in your inbox. Get the Newsday Now newsletter!


Newsday.com now uses Facebook for our comment boards. Please read our guidelines and connect your Facebook account to comment.

You also may be interested in: