The Fishery (East Rockaway)
1 Main St. East Rockaway, NY 516-256-7117
Critic rating:
Persistent cool, drizzly weather leaves me imagining how lovely it must be eating out on the deck of The Fishery. Yet, even indoors, I appreciate the view of boats bobbing in the basin off East Rockaway Inlet.
Good thing this is one seafood restaurant where the food doesn't take a backseat to the view. I note how crowded the attractive tiled barroom is, and there's virtually no vista there whatsoever.
Hours: Sunday-Thursday: 11:30 a.m.-10 p.m. Friday-Saturday: 11:30 a.m.-11 p.m. Ambience: Good Service: Good Credit cards: Accepted Accessibility: Wheelchair-accessible
Photo credit: Timothy Fadek, 2009 | A waitress carries a lobster roll platter at The Fishery in East Rockaway.
Persistent cool, drizzly weather leaves me imagining how lovely it must be eating out on the deck of The Fishery. Yet, even indoors, I appreciate the view of boats bobbing in the basin off East Rockaway Inlet.
Good thing this is one seafood restaurant where the food doesn't take a backseat to the view. I note how crowded the attractive tiled barroom is, and there's virtually no vista there whatsoever.
GOOD CATCH: Four of us go to town on the generous chilled raw bar platter for two. At its center is a whole Maine lobster, slightly warm and marine-sweet, surrounded by quartets of cooked jumbo shrimp, raw oysters, littlenecks and cherrystones, all sparkling fresh.
A sampling of four fine chowders is presented in tiny cups: a rich New England, a hearty Manhattan, a chunky fisherman's chowder and a sherry-laced lobster bisque.
I can't think of a more refreshing warm weather dish than the chilled seafood Cobb salad. I'm able to have blue cheese substituted for Cheddar in a bowl piled with cool scallops, shrimp, shredded Maryland crab, avocado, red onion and cherry tomatoes.
In addition to a conventional lobster roll, The Fishery offers a hot one - warm chunks of lobster meat on a grilled hot dog bun with drawn butter; it's simple and ideal. A true indulgence is a special of seafood potpie, capped with puff pastry and filled with shrimp, scallops and lobster in a rich sauce with a tinge of sherry.
There's more opulence in warm bread pudding with cranberries and chocolate chips and in the perilously rich cheesecake, both finales plated with fresh whipped cream.
GO FISH: Finely shredded Maryland crab meat makes for a tight-textured crab cake. And a broiled combo features bread-y baked clams plus paprika-dusted shrimp, scallops and flounder with heavily battered sweet potato fries and broccoli. So boring, so 1970s.
BOTTOM LINE: Small shortcomings aside, this is one you'll want to reel in.
Lobster roll: At this seaside fish house with outdoor seating, there are two varieties, each made with the meat of one lobster. The cold roll features lobster salad made to order with a dressing of mayo, Old Bay seasoning, lemon, chives and parsley. The hot roll features lobster meat quickly warmed with a touch of drawn butter that's drizzled on the bun and also served on the side. Each costs $16.95 and comes with coleslaw and fries. The bottom line? The hot lobster roll may look small, but it's a purist's dream - just lobster and a little butter. The cold one is good, too.
Rock music: Live bands take the stage from 10 p.m.-1 a.m. every Friday and Saturday.