Long Island high school senior superlatives through the years

+-

High school student bodies often take stock of the notable personalities getting ready to graduate, celebrating them as the best at something — and occasionally, that prediction rings true throughout their lives. See if you recognize any of these Long Islanders pegged as senior superlatives among their peers in past years.

And if you have any senior superlatives you want featured on newsday.com, email josh.stewart@newsday.com.

Most School Spirited

Joseph Genalo and Joan Ebtinger were chosen to
(Credit: Bellmore-Merrick Central High School District)

Joseph Genalo and Joan Ebtinger were chosen to be the most school spirited among their peers in Wellington C. Mepham High School Class of 1962.

Most Popular

Suzanne Meyer and Ted Davies were decided the
(Credit: Patchogue Medford School District)

Suzanne Meyer and Ted Davies were decided the most popular students of Patchogue-Medford High School's Class of 1958.

Most Talented

Teddy Castellucci and Cathy Proper were chosen as
(Credit: Lindenhurst Union Free School District)

Teddy Castellucci and Cathy Proper were chosen as the most talented people in Lindenhurst Senior High School's Class of 1983. Castellucci went on to find success as a music composer in the movie industry, including several Adam Sandler films; he even appeared onscreen as a musician in "The Wedding Singer" (1998).

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISE HERE

Best Dressed

Tracey Dean and Pat Harris were named as
(Credit: Riverhead Central School District)

Tracey Dean and Pat Harris were named as the "best dressed" students among their peers at the Riverhead High School Class of 1983.

Class Clown

Patti Ann LuPone was deemed the female
(Credit: Northport-East Northport Union Free School District)

Patti Ann LuPone was deemed the female "class clown" of Northport High School's Class of 1967, as well as the "most musical" and "most dramatic," and the caption next to her head shot states she was "the most well known person in school." LuPone went on to become a star of stage and screen, winning two Tony Awards and two Grammy Awards, starred in several TV shows and in such films as "Witness" (1985) and "Driving Miss Daisy" (1989).

Best Smile

Frank Esposito and Sue Siegler were deemed to
(Credit: Island Trees Union Free School District)

Frank Esposito and Sue Siegler were deemed to have the "best smiles" among their schoolmates in the Island Trees High School Class of 1990.

Biggest Prevaricator

Today, this might be called
(Credit: Islip Union Free School District)

Today, this might be called "biggest quibbler." James Reidy was chosen by his peers in the Islip High School's Class of 1940 as the "biggest prevaricator" among the seniors.

Most Popular

Martha Kemp and Brain Winslow were chosen as
(Credit: Carle Place Union Free School District)

Martha Kemp and Brain Winslow were chosen as the "most popular" students in Carle Place High School's Class of 1966.

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISE HERE

Most Scholarly

Keith Vetter and Mary Gagliardo were named
(Credit: North Babylon Union Free School District)

Keith Vetter and Mary Gagliardo were named "most scholarly" students of the North Babylon High School Class of 1961.

Bob Ciulla and Patti Andrejewski were determined to
(Credit: Lindenhurst Union Free School District)

Bob Ciulla and Patti Andrejewski were determined to be the "best singers" among their peers in the Lindenhurst Senior High School Class of 1971. If Andrejewski looks familiar, it could be because she went on to become a Grammy Award-winning rock star, performing under the name Pat Benatar.

Wildest Hair

The
(Credit: East Islip Public Library)

The "Wildest Hair" superlative was awarded to Alison Haimes and Kevin Birmingham of East Islip High School in 1998.

Nuttiest

Tara Ledesma and Matt McManus were voted
(Credit: East Islip Public Library)

Tara Ledesma and Matt McManus were voted "Nuttiest" by their peers at East Islip High School in 1998. Ledesma is quoted in the yearbook as saying, "Tara Vision: It's the wave of the future!"

Most Unique

Liz Iacullo and Feng Zheng were named
(Credit: East Islip Public Library)

Liz Iacullo and Feng Zheng were named "Most Unique" in the 2006 East Islip High School yearbook. Iacullo holds up a sign that reads: "We should have won 'Best Looking!' "

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISE HERE

Most Dramatic

The student body of Plainview-Old Bethpage John F.
(Credit: Plainview‑Old Bethpage Central School District)

The student body of Plainview-Old Bethpage John F. Kennedy High School has shown to have a knack for recognizing talent, especially when senior John Youngs was named the school's Class of 1967's "Most Dramatic" male (senior Chyrl Dembroff was chosen the Most Dramatic female student). Youngs is better known today as actor John Savage, who has appeared in several major motion pictures, including such notable films as "The Deer Hunter" (1978), "Do the Right Thing" (1989) and "The Godfather Part III" (1990).

Typical Seniors

Allison Packert and Ken Randazzo were named the
(Credit: Levittown Union Free School District)

Allison Packert and Ken Randazzo were named the most "Typical Seniors" of MacArthur High School's Class of 1989.

Most Likely to Succeed

Plainview-Old Bethpage John F. Kennedy High School's Class
(Credit: Plainview‑Old Bethpage Central School District)

Plainview-Old Bethpage John F. Kennedy High School's Class of 1980 voted their classmates Josh Metlay and Diane Franklin the seniors "Most Likely to Succeed." Franklin was also picked as the female "Class Dramatist," and the nods ended up foretelling decisions, as Diane went on to star in several major motion pictures, including such '80's hits as "Better Off Dead," (1985) "Bill and Ted's Excellent Adventure" (1989) and "The Last American Virgin" (1982).

Most Sincere

Ole Juul Gram Mary Ellen Wazlo was deemed
(Credit: East Hampton Union Free School District )

Ole Juul Gram Mary Ellen Wazlo was deemed "Most Sincere" of all the students of East Hampton High School's Class of 1959. (Notable fact: Ole was an exchange student from Denmark, yet still won the "Sincere" vote over all the other boys in his class.)

Best Dressed

Hal Dunn and Denise Realmuto were named as
(Credit: Baldwin School District)

Hal Dunn and Denise Realmuto were named as the "Best Dressed" students among their peers in the Baldwin High School Class of 1973.

Teachers' Trials

Brian McCreedy and Lydia Berglin were determined to
(Credit: Hampton Bays Union Free School District)

Brian McCreedy and Lydia Berglin were determined to be the top "Teachers' Trials" among their peers in the Hampton Bays High School Class of 1958.

Most Literary

East Meadow High School students Glenn Korman and
(Credit: East Meadow Union Free School District)

East Meadow High School students Glenn Korman and Janet Bronstein were chosen as the "Most Literary" members of their class, the Class of 1978, by their peers.

Most Likely to Weasel Out of Trouble

Wantagh High School Class of 1995 members Colin
(Credit: Wantagh Union Free School District)

Wantagh High School Class of 1995 members Colin Higbee and Michele Mirro were chosen as the students "Most Likely to Weasel Out of Trouble."

Most Cosmopolitan

Dave Boiles and Mary Mellon were named the
(Credit: Kings Park Central School District)

Dave Boiles and Mary Mellon were named the "Most Cosmopolitan" students among their peers in King Park High School's Class of 1973.

Most Popular

Kathleen Rowse was chosen by her classmates as
(Credit: Patchogue Medford School District)

Kathleen Rowse was chosen by her classmates as the Most Popular girl of the Patchogue-Medford High School Class of 1929.

Best Dancers

Carol Scheckman and David Cohen were chosen by
(Credit: Bellmore–Merrick Central High School District)

Carol Scheckman and David Cohen were chosen by their classmates as the Best Dancers of the Sanford H. Calhoun High School Senior Class of 1960.

Best dressed

Senior Joann Forman was picked by her classmates
(Credit: Levittown Public School District)

Senior Joann Forman was picked by her classmates as the Best Dressed female student in Levittown Memorial High School Class of 1960.

Most Individual

Seniors Kevin Fagan and Mela Catanzaro were chosen
(Credit: Valley Stream Central High School District)

Seniors Kevin Fagan and Mela Catanzaro were chosen as the "Most Individual" students in the Valley Stream Central High School Class of 1984.

Nicest Hair

Sayville students Megan Mall and Matt Duerr were
(Credit: Sayville Public School District )

Sayville students Megan Mall and Matt Duerr were deemed the students with the Nicest Hair in the Class of 1989.

Nicest Eyes

Donna Berry and Doug Koch were designated the
(Credit: Levittown Public School District)

Donna Berry and Doug Koch were designated the students with the Nicest Eyes in the Division Avenue High School Class of 1990.

Best Dressed

Shawn Dillon and Tarnita Sumpter were chosen by
(Credit: Longwood Central School District)

Shawn Dillon and Tarnita Sumpter were chosen by their peers as the Best Dressed male and female students of the Longwood High School Class of 1991.

Wiliest

Billy Crystal, Dee Dee Rosenberg and Eileen Nad
(Credit: Long Beach City School District)

Billy Crystal, Dee Dee Rosenberg and Eileen Nad were chosen the three "Williest" [sic] students of Long Beach High School's Class of 1965. Crystal has since proved he is indeed shrewd, going on star in such movies as "The Princess Bride," "Throw Momma from the Train," "When Harry Met Sally," "Analyze This" and "Monsters, Inc.," while also spending a season as a cast member on the iconic NBC TV show "Saturday Night Live."

Best Smile

Seniors Pam Frank and Noah Yosha were chosen
(Credit: Bellmore–Merrick Central High School District)

Seniors Pam Frank and Noah Yosha were chosen by their classmates as having the Best Smile of the John F. Kennedy High School Class of 1995.

Class Clowns

Jay Acham and Diane James were named the
(Credit: Middle Country Central School District)

Jay Acham and Diane James were named the Class Clowns in the Newfield High School Class of 1997.

Class Clown

Amy Schumer in her
(Credit: Rockville Centre School District )

Amy Schumer in her "Class Comedian" South Side High School Class of 1999 yearbook photo.

Most Involved

The Mineola High School Class of 2000 chose
(Credit: Mineola School District)

The Mineola High School Class of 2000 chose Lauren Scala as the Most Involved female member of their class. The 2000 Homecoming King Vishal Gandhi, left, was the male choice. Scala was also the Homecoming Queen. She's currently a reporter and TV personality working for the WNBC programs "Today in New York" and "New York Live."

Most Theatrical

North Shore High School's Class of 2002 named
(Credit: North Shore School District)

North Shore High School's Class of 2002 named Kate Berthold the Most Theatrical and Funniest female of the senior class. She performs, above, with Most Theatrical male senior Perry Krug. Kate's fellow students must have been on to something, as Kate -- now known as actress Kate McKinnon -- is a cast member of NBC's "Saturday Night Live" and co-star in the "Ghostbusters" film reboot.

Get the Newsday Now newsletter!

The best of Newsday every day in your inbox.

Sign up

By clicking Sign up, you agree to our privacy policy.

Related Media

Kate McKinnon graduated from North Shore High School Meet 150 notable LI high school alumni This 1958 Bridgehampton High School senior had a Guess who: LI celebrity yearbook pictures Up-dos with cornrows and butterfly clips were all Throwback LI prom photos: Spot your BFF!

Comments

Newsday.com now uses Facebook for our comment boards. Please read our guidelines and connect your Facebook account to comment.

By using this site, you agree to our Privacy policy.

OK
Sorry to interrupt...

Your first 5 are free

Access to Newsday is free for Optimum customers.

Please enjoy 5 complimentary views to articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.

LOGIN SUBSCRIBE