Seven LI hospitals make 'safest' list

Winthrop-University Hospital in Mineola was ranked as one

Winthrop-University Hospital in Mineola was ranked as one of the safest hospitals in America, according to an annual statewide hospital report card. (July 29, 2013) Photo Credit: Newsday / John Paraskevas

advertisement | advertise on newsday

Seven Long Island hospitals were deemed among "America's safest" and two were placed on a "patient safety watch" list in an annual statewide hospital report card.

In the 10th annual report card published Sunday by the Niagara Health Quality Coalition, most of the area's hospitals scored at the state average in up to 27 measures of death rates or patient safety -- such as deaths from stroke or pneumonia or postoperative infections. The report card, which also looked at five measures of patient satisfaction, used data from 2011.

Nassau University Medical Center in East Meadow and Plainview Hospital, part of the North Shore-Long Island Jewish Health System, were among 17 that the coalition placed on the "patient safety watch" list.

Bruce Boissonnault, chief executive of the nonprofit group based near Buffalo, said the watch list is based on the proportion of "worse" scores -- that is, below the state average -- a hospital received in mortality and patient safety. Conversely, those on the "safest" list were those with the highest proportion of above-average rankings.

Close to a third of the 23 hospitals the coalition designated "safest" were from Long Island: John T. Mather Memorial Hospital in Port Jefferson; Franklin Hospital in Valley Stream; Long Island Jewish Medical Center in New Hyde Park; North Shore University Hospital in Manhasset; St. Catherine of Siena Medical Center in Smithtown; St. Francis Hospital in Roslyn, and Winthrop-University Hospital in Mineola.

Terry Lynam, spokesman for North Shore-LIJ -- which had three hospitals on the "safest" list and one on the "watch" list -- said in an email: "Regardless of how our hospitals are rated in these reports, we use the information so we can continually improve patient safety and quality of care."

advertisement | advertise on newsday

Shelley Lotenberg, spokeswoman for Nassau University Medical Center, part of NuHealth, said she "strongly disagrees with the characterization by the Niagara report that we are a 'watchlist' hospital."

"The facts are that NuHealth has been the recipient of numerous national awards for the care it provides, in many areas its care is ranked amongst the best delivered anywhere on Long Island and we expect to continue to deliver the highest quality care to the Island's most vulnerable populations," she said.

Boissonnault said people shouldn't necessarily avoid a "watch list" hospital but should examine results in those clinical areas where they are likely to need care, and talk with their doctors. "These are rare events but if it happens to you, it's 100 percent," he said.


The coalition said that since 2002, when it first began publishing its report card, mortality rates statewide have improved by about 50 percent. Of the 10 hospital error rates the coalition measures, eight have improved, although surgical infection rates continue to worsen, the coalition said.

To look at the report card, go to

Mortality rates at Long Island hospitals
The Niagra Health Quality Coalition rated hospitals in New York State on a variety of measures. Here is a sampling of mortality rates published by the organization. In six cases, a rate was not available because the number of patients involved was too small.

HospitalHeart attack Acute stroke Pneumonia Hip fracturesCongestive heart failure
Brookhaven Memorial Hospital Medical Center, Patchogue10.5%20.6%4.4%5.2%4.1%
Eastern Long Island Hospital, GreenportN/AN/A4.5%0.0%5.7%
Franklin Hospital Medical Center, Valley Stream15.9%8.2%3.4%2.4%3.1%
Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center, West Islip4.9%15.0%4.1%3.0%2.8%
Huntington Hospital, Huntington6.3%9.5%2.8%0.5%3.0%
John T Mather Memorial Hospital, Port Jefferson4.0%3.7%2.9%3.2%2.2%
Long Beach Medical Center, Long BeachN/A4.3%5.1%4.4%4.2%
Long Island Jewish Medical Center2.46.34.3%3.1%2.1%
Mercy Medical Center, Rockville Centre3.6%7.4%6.5%1.5%3.1%
Nassau University Medical Center, East Meadow14.1%27.3%4.9%3.4%4.5%
North Shore University Hospital, Glen Cove9.8%7.9%1.6%3.8%2.4%
North Shore University Hospital, Manhasset3.4%15.4%2.9%1.9%3.1%
Peconic Bay Medical Center, Riverhead10.3%13.4%4.0%3.2%3.4%
Plainview Hospital, Plainview8.2%9.1%4.8%2.5%5.4%
South Nassau Communities Hospital, Oceanside6.9%11.8%4.2%2.5%4.3%
Southampton Hospital, SouthamptonN/A8.2%3.5%6.2%3.4%
Southside Hospital, Bayshore4.6%10.1%2.7%0.0%1.7%
St. Catherine of Siena Medical Center, Smithtown4.5%7.2%4.1%6.3%3.5%
St. Charles Hospital, Port JeffersonN/A5.3%2.9%0.0%3.3%
St. Francis Hospital-The Heart Center, Roslyn4.8%7.5%3.5%0.0%3.0%
St. Joseph's Hospital, Bethpage11.4%15.6%3.6%0.0%5.7%
SUNY/Stony Brook University Hospital, Stony Brook3.3%12.5%4.1%3.7%2.9%
Syosset Hospital, Syosset9.9%N/A6.7%1.6%7.7%
Winthrop-University Hospital, Mineola3.9%7.7%2.0%2.5%3.0%
Statewide rate5.512.33.6%2.7%3.1%

Comments now uses Facebook for our comment boards. Please read our guidelines and connect your Facebook account to comment.

You also may be interested in: