Text size: increase text sizedecrease text size

Letter reveals Marshall planned to kill

About the same time a case worker at Evan Marshall's upstate rehabilitation clinic was writing a glowing memo about his progress last year, Marshall was authoring a bloodcurdling note of his own, a prosecutor revealed for the first time Wednesday in court.

"Two months to go. Don't Give up," it read, prosecutor Mitchell Benson said in court. Marshall then began his to-do list:

"Talk to a guy. Be careful. Don't get caught. Move into another rehab program. Kill a girl. ... Do cocaine off her corpse. Do more cocaine. Do more cocaine. Do more cocaine."

At the end of it, Marshall wrote, "Next time I do cocaine, I will kill a girl."

That was just weeks before Marshall killed schoolteacher Denice Fox, allegedly while high on cocaine, a crime that rocked the community for its brutality.

Marshall's lawyer, William Keahon of Islandia, would not comment on the note or on Benson's suggestion that Marshall's crime was premeditated.

Benson juxtaposed the case worker's confidence that Marshall was making progress against the to-do list, which he said showed that Marshall was sinking deeper into psychosis. He said no matter how much progress correction officials think Marshall makes in the next 30 years, he will always be a danger to society.

"It will never be safe," Benson said.

Related topic galleries: Addiction, Prosecution

Get breaking news | Most popular stories | Dining and Travel deals all via e-mail!

Crime in Pictures

Long Island mugshots Long Island mug shots

Recent arrests in Nassau and Suffolk.

Teacher sex scandals Teacher sex scandals

Notorious local and national scandals between teachers and students.

DWI mugshots Nassau DWI sting

Nassau County officials released the mug shots of recent arrests in a DWI sting.

Special Projects

The Katie Trebing story The fight for civil rights

Local leaders, then and now, reflect on doing their part to push for equality.

The Katie Trebing story The Katie Trebing story

A daughter with a deadly disease, an extraordinary chance to save her...create the perfect sibling.

They Failed to Act They Failed to Act

Since 1995, the Long Island Rail Road has logged nearly 900 gap incidents at stations from Penn to Bridgehampton.

Born to Serve Born to Serve

Michael P. Murphy's actions in June, 2005 earned him, posthumously, the nation's highest military award.

Coram station Fire Alarm

The only comprehensive look at the last large public service on Long Island impervious to outside scrutiny - the fire system.

Coram station Remembering Flight 800

On the beach at Smith Point County Park is a monument with the names of the 230 passengers and crew from Flight 800.

Our Fallen Our Fallen

Soldiers from Long Island killed in uniform reflect the face of our communities. Newsday remembers their sacrifice.


Newsday's Vlog

Long Island video blog

Watch Newsday-produced videos and share your thoughts on the topics at hand.

Impact of high gas prices

With record fuel prices on LI, drivers and businesses try to cope as best they can.
Share your story.
Find cheap gas

My Long Island

Long Island user photos
Your life in photos

Your faces. Your cameras. Your life. Upload your photos now.