WASHINGTON -- One month before the deadline, negotiations between President Barack Obama and Republicans to save the economy from a plunge over the fiscal cliff are still in the throat-clearing stage. Serious bargaining is on hold while the two sides vie for political leverage.
Deal or no deal, nothing is likely to become clear until far closer to the year-end deadline, when the lure of getting away for the holidays will sharpen the focus of negotiators.
"There's a stalemate. Let's not kid ourselves," House Speaker John Boehner (R-Ohio) said Friday, punctuating the end of a week of political theater by divided government. "Right now we're almost nowhere."
He spoke as Obama all but called Republicans heartless louts from a Charles Dickens story. Their failure to pass an extension of middle class tax cuts would amount to a Christmas "lump of coal" for millions, Obama said in Hatfield, Pa. "That's a Scrooge Christmas," added the recently re-elected president, who claims a voters' mandate to extend existing tax cuts for all but upper incomes.
Boehner also claimed a mandate after voters renewed the House Republican majority on Nov. 6. But the speaker's political hand was weakened -- witness his postelection announcement that the GOP would put revenue on the bargaining table. His control seems to have eroded further in the weeks since, as a smattering of the GOP rank-and-file let it be known they could support Obama's tax plan under the right circumstances.
"Rate increase, if the package includes significant entitlement reform that gets you to $4 to $6 trillion [in deficit savings] over 10 years, I would vote for that," a retiring Rep. Steve LaTourette (R-Ohio) told reporters Friday.
In the talks to date, Democrats have declined to identify a single spending cut they are willing to support, while Republicans avoid specifics on revenue increases they would swallow.
Once each side moves beyond opening gambits, Republicans will have to decide whether they are willing to raise income tax rates on upper incomes, as Obama wants, or hold fast to closing loopholes as a means of producing increased tax revenue.
For their part, Democrats will decide how much savings to pull from benefit programs like Medicare, Medicaid and possibly Social Security without cutting guaranteed benefits, a line they vowed not to cross in earlier budget negotiations.
Obama's opening proposal, delivered to Boehner and other Republicans by Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner on Thursday, calls for $1.6 trillion in higher taxes over a decade, hundreds of billions of dollars in new spending, a possible extension of the temporary Social Security payroll tax cut and enhancing the president's power to raise the national debt limit.
The new federal revenue would include $950 billion generated by raising taxes on families with incomes over $250,000 and by closing certain tax loopholes by the end of this year, according to administration officials who described the offer Friday. The remainder would be achieved through an overhaul of the tax system next year.
In exchange, the president would back spending cuts of an unspecified amount this year, and savings of as much as $400 billion from Medicare and other benefit programs in 2013.
Republicans said they were surprised at the plan, and Democrats wondered aloud why.
"Each side said they'd submit a down payment. We have. Our preference is revenue. What is theirs?" said Sen. Charles Schumer (D-N.Y.).
Republicans have an opening offer of their own, in line with their conservative anti-tax views. While agreeing to new revenue, GOP lawmakers want to extend expiring income tax cuts at all levels, including the top brackets.
They also want to raise the age of eligibility for Medicare and curtail future cost-of-living adjustments for Social Security and other benefit programs. The same adjustment would raise revenue for the government by making a change in annual adjustments of tax brackets.