It's rare that you can look at your television screen and see not only what is happening but also what might have been. Chris Christie's inaugural address Tuesday was at once a masterful summary of the best thinking among Republicans about where their party needs to move, and a compendium of proclamations that now carry unfortunate double meanings.
The New Jersey governor gave the speech he would have given had there been no George Washington Bridge scandal and no allegations about the use of superstorm Sandy relief money to pressure a local official on a development project.
You can't blame him for sticking to the old script. He now has to live his public life on two levels. And Christie's speech made an important contribution: The tough former prosecutor denounced our dysfunctional, counterproductive approach to the drug problem.
"We will end the failed war on drugs that believes that incarceration is the cure of every ill caused by drug abuse," he declared. "We will make drug treatment available to as many of our nonviolent offenders as we can . . . every life has value and no life is disposable."
Forget the scandals for a moment: Christie here is speaking for an expanding consensus that (forgive me) bridges left and right about the foolishness of filling our prisons with those who are victims of their own crimes. Pushing this cause along could be Christie's good deed.
But like everything else in the speech, this passage also had a political purpose. Offering a dash of libertarianism, which appeals to a key subset of the Republican primary electorate, with a soupçon of compassion is just what the consultant gods would order up. And that's the sort of balance Christie struck throughout.
For the tea party ideologues, Christie dutifully mocked "the power of almighty government to fix any problem, real or imagined." He fired a shot across the Hudson River, aimed perhaps New York City mayor Bill de Blasio. "Let's be different than our neighbors," he said. "Let's put more money in the pockets of our middle class by not taking it out of their pockets in the first place." And even Rand Paul couldn't do better than this: "I do not believe that New Jerseyans want a bigger, more expensive government that penalizes success and then gives the pittance left to a few in the name of income equity."
But the ideology came draped in the finery of anti-partisan, anti-gridlock fashion, finished off with a resurgent, caring brand of conservatism. "We have to be willing to play outside the red and blue boxes that the media pundits put us in," said the man who also has other reasons for disliking the media.
On a normal day, the once pro-Christie media would have gone into a swoon. But there's a new normal for the man who once led the GOP presidential polls. Suddenly, anodyne pronouncements sounded strange.
When he said "each vote cast is an act of faith and trust," Christie reminded everyone that a breach of trust is why he's in trouble. When he praised his state for having "put aside political partisanship," his listeners remembered that hardball is his calling card. When he criticized an "attitude that says I am always right and you are always wrong," you wondered if he described what The New York Times called his "swagger."
For there was other news on inauguration day, including a Pew poll finding that 58 percent of those who've heard about the bridge story don't believe Christie's account. Ken Cuccinelli, the GOP's defeated 2013 candidate for governor of Virginia, said Christie should step down as chairman of the Republican Governors Association. And New Jersey's legislators consolidated their investigation of him into one committee.
Aside from all this, Christie had a great day. But for now, "all this" is what defines him.
E.J. Dionne Jr. is a columnist for The Washington. He can be reached at email@example.com.