Upload Photo
10. ALEX RODRIGUEZThird base, 2004-currentPeople might think he
Caption / Share

10. ALEX RODRIGUEZ
Third base, 2004-current
People might think he has not been a Yankee long enough to make this list, but he already has seven 100-RBI seasons in Pinstripes, which is three more than Mantle had. He has won two MVP awards and two American League home run titles since he has been in New York. The first since Ruth to hit his 600th career home run as a Yankee. His 18 RBIs in the 2009 postseason are a franchise record, and A-Rod would have to be considered the top third baseman in Yankees history.(Credit: Getty)

1 of 10

Share this photo

Countdown: Top 10 Yankees of all-time

If ever there were to be a baseball version of Mount Rushmore, it would look an awful lot like Monument Park in Yankee Stadium. Choosing the all-time Top 10 Yankees is both easy and impossible. Their key Mount Rushmore figures come to mind in an instant, but the problem is, how do you limit the list to 10? Newsday's Mark Herrmann tries.