Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza

137 Old Country Rd. Carle Place, NY 516 877.7750

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza in Carle Place. (Jan.

(Credit: Ian J. Stark)

Submit a photo »

Critic rating: 3

User rating:
3
(7) Click to rate
Type: Pizza Price range: $$ (Moderate) Description:

Pizza and sandwiches baked in an 800-degree oven, plus salads and Italian food.

Hours: Mon-Sat: 11:30 a.m.-10 p.m.; Sun: 12:30 p.m.-10 p.m. Ambience: Fair Service: Fair Credit cards: Accepted
Patrons dine at Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza restaurant

Patrons dine at Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza restaurant in Woodbury. (Sept. 30, 2011) (Credit: Yana Paskova)

3

A food-induced OMG moment comes along rarely enough. But at a chain restaurant? Practically unthinkable. And yet, here I am, experiencing one such moment after another at Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza, a Florida-based franchise founded by Long Island native Anthony Bruno.

At both Long Island branches, virtually everything is cooked in an 800-degree coal oven. Results can be magical.

ALL FIRED UP

Pork ribs roasted with garlic, rosemary, spicy vinegar peppers and white wine emerge tender, juicy, truly fierce. I'm amazed how light, luxurious and knowingly seasoned the meatballs (served with ricotta) turn out. Flying from the coal oven, chicken wings soar. They're lightly charred, topped with caramelized onion and served with fine focaccia. I'm a big fan of eggplant Marino (named for chain partner NFL great Dan Marino), an ethereal layering of eggplant, cheese and tomato sauce.

The house salad -- romaine, chickpeas, celery, onions, Kalamata olives, tomato, hard-boiled eggs in red wine vinaigrette -- seems just what nonna might make. Kick it up with Gorgonzola, if you wish.

What really gets my heart pumping is the roasted cauliflower pizza. Ovoid in shape, it's crowned with the usually pungent cruciferous vegetable tamed into sweet, mellow submission after being roasted with olive oil and garlic, showered with Romano, mozzarella and bread crumbs. And, oh, that gorgeously charred, crisp and flavor-rich crust. Even sandwiches (such as the lemony tuna with olive oil, lemon and arugula) are superior, thanks to house-baked bread.

COOLING OFF

While the signature tomato and cheese pizza is very good, it can't touch that cauliflower pie. Several notches below is the good-not-great Philly cheesesteak pizza.

Be forewarned: the din can be deafening. Twice, servers took orders without writing them down (not the general rule, I'm told) and forgot items.

BOTTOM LINE

Go early or you'll wait forever.

advertisement | advertise on newsday

Where

Get directions

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza 137 Old Country Rd., Carle Place

advertisement | advertise on newsday