One school of thought as the NHL trade deadline approaches on the 27th is that the Rangers should avoid acquiring Rick Nash of the Columbus Blue Jackets, who visit the Garden tonight, and instead fill in around the edges, with a rental forward and defenseman, and allow the team to grow and mature.
The premise? That this Rangers team, with 79 points, already is potent enough to make a deep playoff run, that Nash would disrupt chemistry and that his $7.8-million annual cost would damage the salary cap for years, as well as cripple the farm system.
Latest Rangers stories
Here's one argument for Nash, a 27-year-old power forward who can create, carry and finish to the tune of 30 to 40 goals a season. Consider: Stars such as Nash don't come down the road every year. It's rare in this age of clubs locking up young talent to long-term deals.
Henrik Lundqvist, the Rangers' MVP, repeatedly has said his clock is ticking; that after seven years, he badly wants to play in June, i.e., the Stanley Cup Finals. Does Lundqvist deserve to make some serious runs at the Cup in his prime? Or will his best years -- and dreams -- go unfulfilled like another great New York athlete, Don Mattingly?
So why not spend some assets on a potential difference-maker? The Eastern Conference berth in the Finals is wide open. Lundqvist has been amazing and the defense is willing to sacrifice life and limb. But is there enough scoring? Doubtful. And what happens if Marian Gaborik, Brad Richards or Ryan Callahan is injured in March, when the team plays 17 games in 30 days?
The Rangers could be scary with Nash in the top six and on the power play.
If the Rangers refuse to include top prospect Chris Kreider in any deal (understandable), they could offer Brandon Dubinsky, Tim Erixon or J.T. Miller (whom The Hockey News poll of scouts rate as their No. 2 and 3 prospects) and a No. 1 pick in June (which likely will be in the lower third of the first round). Or more. Perhaps Carl Hagelin or a high pick in 2013 could be dangled.
The Rangers sent two second-rounders and prospect Roman Horak to Calgary for Erixon, who was a No. 1 pick of Montreal. But will Erixon unseat Dan Girardi, Michael Del Zotto, Ryan McDonagh or Marc Staal to crack the top four in the next two years? Don't think so.
Along with Erixon and Miller, the Rangers have stockpiled more prospects than they have for a decade: punishing d-man Dylan McIlrath, Christian Thomas (son of former NHLer Steve Thomas), Swedish forward Jesper Fasth, Minnesota high school star Steven Fogarty (committed to Notre Dame), Edmonton Oil Kings center Michael St. Croix (a top-six scorer in the WHL) and Kelowna Rockets center Shane McColgan.
And it's not as if there are no youngsters on the current roster. Eight regulars are 25 or under: Derek Stepan, 21; Del Zotto, 21; McDonagh, 22; Artem Anisimov, 23; Hagelin, 23; Michael Sauer, 24; Staal, 25, and Anton Stralman, 25.
Nash, a world-class left wing, is a huge upgrade over Dubinsky, who will have better years. And Kreider, whose speed is astonishing for a 6-3 winger, could step in for Hagelin. Another improvement.
For those worried about future cap issues, such as what to do when Gaborik's $7.5-million-per contract is up in two years, well, would you rather have Nash at 29 or extend Gaborik at 32?
The complicating issue is whether Nash, who reportedly will waive his no- trade clause for the Rangers and a select few other teams, will be moved by the 27th. Columbus has an interim coach (Todd Richards) and lame-duck general manager (Scott Howson). Does Nash want to be around for another Ohio rebuild? Or come to a contender?
Henrik and roll
In HBO's 24/7 goaltender/guitarist Henrik Lundqvist was filmed jamming with John McEnroe and Jay Weinberg, the son of E Street Band drummer Max Weinberg. They've added three other musicians for Noise Upstairs, a benefit concert on Wednesday, Feb. 22 at 8 p.m. at The Canal Room in lower Manhattan. The $150 tickets can be obtained by invitation/registration at www.rockofdreams.com. Proceeds go to the Garden of Dreams and The Johnny Mac Tennis Project.