New York, New York: Homegrown talent who rose to stardom in the Big Apple

5. Phil Rizzuto Discovered by Yankees scout Paul

5. Phil Rizzuto
Discovered by Yankees scout Paul Krichell at a semipro game in Floral Park after having been told by the Dodgers and Giants he was too small to play shortstop in the big leagues, the product of Richmond Hill, Brooklyn, loomed large as a Yankees fixture for generations. He made the Hall of Fame as a key member of seven championship clubs and as the American League MVP in 1950—and then served as a beloved longtime broadcaster.
Notable quote: “Holy cow!”
Photo Credit: AP, 1950

advertisement | advertise on newsday

"You Can't Go Home Again" is the title of a 1940 novel by Thomas Wolfe. It is important to note that it was a work of fiction, and not a true epigram. You sure couldn't prove it by the New York athletes who grew up to become prominent professional stars in New York.

New Yorkers know better than anyone what a humbling place this can be, especially for players on the home teams. To borrow another familiar line: "If you can make it here, you can make it anywhere." Still, you can, indeed, make it here if you are from here. The current "M--V--P" chants for Brooklyn native Carmelo Anthony of the Knicks are the latest evidence. Although Anthony did spend formative years in Baltimore, he considers his time at Madison Square Garden as homecoming. Fans think of it that way, too.

Local kid makes good, to the delight of fellow locals: It has happened more than a few times, as you can see from this following presentation.

All 25 of these athletes were born and/or raised in the five boroughs or Long Island. They were chosen on how they performed specifically in the New York phase of their professional careers. So you won't find Sandy Koufax, Joe Torre, Nate Archibald or Boomer Esiason because their best playing days occurred elsewhere.

What you will find are standouts whose achievements (championships definitely counted in composing the list) say that you surely can go home again.


advertisement | advertise on newsday

About our list

The critera:

- Athletes had to be from New York, either born and/or raised in the five boroughs or Long Island
- They needed to make their mark specifically in the New York phase of their pro careers
- Championships won definitely counted

Subscribe to Newsday’s sports newsletter for stories, photos and videos about your favorite New York teams plus national sports news and events.

Comments now uses Facebook for our comment boards. Please read our guidelines and connect your Facebook account to comment.

You also may be interested in: