Restaurants in Montauk

Many of the restaurants in Montauk feature outdoor dining. Quite a few have beautiful views of the water. Some are just quick-hit places for pizza or a sandwich.


Below is a list of eateries in Montauk, broken down by area. Within Montauk Proper (Main Street and the surrounding streets near the beach), restaurants are also broken down by type.

Montauk Village

Fine Dining

Aqua East
17 S. Edison Street
631-668-4147

Bird on the Roof
47 S. Elmwood Avenue
631-668-5833

East by Northeast
51 Edgemere Road
631-668-2872

Nick's
148 S. Emerson Avenue
631-668-4800

Oyster Pond
South Elmwood Avenue
631-668-4200

Shagwong Restaurant
774 Main Street
631-668-3050

Surfside Inn
685 Old Montauk Highway
631-668-5958

The Harvest on Fort Pond
11 S. Emery Street
631-668-5574

The Lakeside
183 Edgemere Street
631-668-3455

Luigi's
So. Euclid Avenue
631-668-3212

Trail's End Restaurant
Edgemere Street
631-668-2133

The Crow's Nest
Montauk Highway & Old West Lake Drive
631-668-2077
Eastern-most restaurant on Long Island

Ruschmeyers
Second House Road
631-668-2877

Cafes, Burger Joints and Breakfast Places

Breakwater Cafe
236 Edgemere Street (at Montauk Manor)
631-668-3949

MKT Cafe
Main Street
A breakfast, lunch and dinner cafe

The Plaza Restaurant
752 Main Street
631-668-9500
Diner-style eatery

668 The Gig Shack
668 Main Street
631-668-2727
Cafe-type food to go with bar and music

John Papas Cafe
126 So. Emerson Avenue
631-668-1511
Beachfront eatery at Royal Atlantic Hotel

John's Drive-In
695 Main Street
631-668-5515
Burgers, hot dogs, milkshakes

The Point Bar & Grille
697 Main Strwoeet
631-668-1500
Pub food, flat-screen TVs and a pool table

O'Murphy's Pub
99 Edgemere Road
631-668-5005
Irish pub

Anthony's Pancake House
Main Street
631-668-9705
A breakfast and lunch place

Mr. John's Pancake & Steak House
721 Main Street
631-668-2383
Famous for its doughnuts

Pizza and such

Sausages
Main Street
Pizzeria and all the accompanying sandwiches and pasta dishes

Primavera Pizza
Flamingo Avenue

Pizza Village
700 Main Street
631-668-2232

Markets and more

Herb's Market
778 Main Street
631-668-2335
Grocery, fried chicken, sandwiches, salads

Naturally Good Food Grocery and Cafe
38 So. Etna Avenue
631-668-9030
A breakfast and lunch place plus market

Dee-licious Bagels
So. Etna Avenue

Continental Market
So. Etna Avenue
631-668-6060

Nelly's Deli
So. Euclid Avenue
631-668-2323

Ronnie's Deli and Grocery
728 Main Street
631-668-2757

Wok N' Roll
716 Main Street
631-668-6688
 Montauk Harbor & Gosman's Dock

Inlet Seafood
541 E. Lake Drive
631-668-4272

fishbar
467 East Lake Drive
631-668-6600

Lenny's on the Dock
494 West Lake Drive
631-668-2500

Dave's Grill
468 West Lake Drive
631-668-9190

Lighthouse Grill
32 Star Island Drive
(at Montauk Yacht Club)
631-668-3100

Gosman's Dock
West Lake Drive
631-668-5330

Gosman's Inlet Cafe and Window Bar
West Lake Drive (within Gosman's Dock shopping area)
631-668-2549
Sushi, sashimi and more

Gosman's Topside Bar
West Lake Drive (within Gosman's Dock shopping area)
Sit atop the cafe for drinks and pub food

Gosman's Clam Bar
West Lake Drive (within Gosman's Dock shopping area)
631-668-2549
Walk-up eatery for fish and more

The Hideaway
364 West Lake Drive
631-668-6592
Mexican, barbecue and seafood

Havana Beach Club Restaurant
448 West Lake Drive
631-668-6677
Cuban cuisine

Salivar's Restaurant
470 West Lake Drive
631-668-2555

The Dock
631-668-9778
Pub food in this local fisherman's place with a great decor

Manucci's
440 West Lake Drive
631-668-4455

Kenny's Tipperary
432 West Lake Drive
631-668-2171

Paddy Wagon
"Home of the Big Dawg" hot dog truck
located at the end of Gosman's Dock
 Napeague

The Lobster Roll
1980 Montauk Highway, Amagansett
631-267-3740

La Fondita
74 Montauk Highway, Amagansett
631-267-8800

Cyril's Fish House
2167 Montauk Highway, Amagansett
631-267-7993

Copyright © 2008, Newsday Inc.

Book Your Trip