Week Six: Mariah Carey Songs

David Cook
"Always Be My Baby"

The Judges' Comments: Randy thinks David will be a hot recording artist and he actually seems to call it the season's best performance to date. Paula reckons the song belongs in a movie soundtrack. "It was like sort of coming out of karaoke hell into a breath of fresh air," Simon gushes. David is overcome by emotion at the end and for those unclear on the circumstances, the camera cuts to his ailing brother in the crowd. This is one of those moments where I won't make an accusation of showboating.