Broadway Commons in Hicksville has placed adhesive decals, described as NanoSeptic "self-cleaning surfaces," on door handles, elevator buttons and other high-touch areas as part of its efforts to make shoppers feel comfortable and safe.
The maker, NanoTouch Materials LLC in Forest, Va., says on its website that NanoSeptic decals have “a mineral nano-crystal which acts as a catalyst, charged by visible light. These nano-crystals create a continuous, powerful oxidation reaction. This oxidation reaction breaks down organic material into base components such as CO2.”
“We’re using them on doors that we’re identifying as entry points,” said Ken Hamilton, general manager of Broadway Commons.
NanoTouch's website doesn't claim that NanoSeptic "skins and mats'' kill COVID-19, but it says they are "continuously self-cleaning surfaces.”
“We are not allowed to make any specific kill claims under our current regulatory environment since NanoSeptic is not an EPA-registered disinfectant," the company said in an email last month. "We worked very hard to create a technology-based green product since EPA-registered disinfectants are strong chemicals or toxins and classified as pesticides.”
NanoTouch declined to give specific sales numbers but says demand has surged amid the pandemic.
"Given that everyone is concerned about hygiene, it makes sense that public-facing organizations like professional sports venues, including NASCAR and the PGA, are deploying NanoSeptic surfaces," Mark Sisson, partner at NanoTouch, said in an email Monday.
The company was shipping a few orders a day last year and now ships about 150 orders daily, he said.
"Many of these orders are fairly large since organizations are purchasing for all of their facilities. For example, a bank’s recent order will cover 750 different branches," he said.
A seller of the NanoSeptic products, Janitronics Facility Services, said the company sold $180,000 worth of NanoSeptic products in April and May to customers including the state comptroller’s office in Albany, UPS, a gym and office building owners and managers, compared to $1,800 worth of NanoSeptic products sold in the three years before the pandemic, the Albany Business Review reported in June. Janitronics did not respond to a Newsday request for comment.
As part of its routine monitoring program, BBB National Programs’ National Advertising Division reviewed advertising claims about NanoSeptic, and said in a report issued July 29 that the six independent lab reports NanoTouch submitted showed that bacteria and viruses are reduced on NanoSeptic surfaces without the use of other antimicrobial cleaning agents.
(Based in Arlington, Va., BBB National Programs is an independent nonprofit whose programs were part of the Council of Better Business Bureaus until June 2019.)
But NAD recommended that NanoTouch stop claiming that NanoSeptic will “turn dirty, high traffic public touchpoints into clean surfaces.” The report said, “While NanoSeptic surfaces may help make those surfaces cleaner ... the evidence does not support the claim that NanoSeptic “turn[s] dirty, high traffic public touchpoints into clean surfaces.”
NanoTouch does not object to NAD's recommendation, Sisson said.
"NAD correctly concluded that we mistakenly used the word 'clean' instead of 'cleaner,' and we completely agree with NAD's suggestion to change the wording to 'cleaner,'" he said.
NanoTouch was founded in 2012 and works with distributors in 30 countries, according to its website. Its research and development lab was funded by a $2 million grant from the Virginia Tobacco Indemnification and Community Revitalization Commission in 2015.The NanoSeptic product line includes handle wraps that can be used at security checkpoints ($45 to $60), a 25-pack of elevator button covers ($49.95) and a 25-pack of door push-bar covers ($137.50), according to an online brochure. The company recommends replacing the adhesive skins every 90 days.
Most malls on Long Island have automatically opening doors, eliminating the need to touch handles, but Broadway Commons does not.
The mall’s El Segundo, California-based parent company, Pacific Retail Capital Partners, has placed the NanoSeptic adhesives in several of its New York shopping centers, including the Colonie Center in Albany and Galleria White Plains, spokeswoman Erin Falbo said.
“NanoSeptic skins are another layer of protection in addition to our already enhanced cleaning protocols based on the CDC guidelines,” Falbo said.
The American Industrial Hygiene Association, a trade group in Falls Church, Va., has seen a significant increase in companies inquiring about how to keep their buildings clean during the pandemic, said board certified industrial hygienist Bernard L. Fontaine, Jr., a member of the association’s Back to Work Safely Task Force.
There is no public scientific evidence to evaluate the claims about NanoSeptic’s effectiveness, so industrial hygiene experts will not be able to give an opinion on the product, he said.
“We have not seen any peer-reviewed scientific studies in the literature and there are no studies provided by the manufacturer to review and consider,” he said.
This story was updated with comments that Mark Sisson, partner at NanoTouch Materials, provided by email Monday.
A note to our community:
As a public service, this article is available for all. Newsday readers support our strong local journalism by subscribing. Please show you value this important work by becoming a subscriber now.SUBSCRIBE