56° Good Afternoon
56° Good Afternoon
ClassifiedsReal Estate

Buying in Lindenhurst, on Long Island’s South Shore

The water's edge at Venetian Shores Park, a

The water's edge at Venetian Shores Park, a resident-only beach along the Great South Bay. Credit: Newsday / J. Conrad Williams Jr.

THE SCOOP Lindenhurst is an affordable area with highly regarded schools, says Jo Ann Boettcher, who is the president of the Lindenhurst Chamber of Commerce and a broker with Douglas Elliman Real Estate. The village has become even more desirable of late, she says, thanks to proposals to redevelop the downtown area.

Newsday reported in June that the village board approved a zoning law that will allow Tritec Real Estate to submit an application for a 260-unit multifamily rental complex across from the Lindenhurst train station.

Mayor Michael Lavorata says that the potential of a transit-oriented development geared to millennials will add to the village’s appeal.

“We already have a uniqueness,” he says of Lindenhurst, “but we’re hoping that it will create a more upscale and attractive area for everyone.”

Earlier this year, in hopes of further revitalizing the area, the village acquired blighted properties to add much-needed parking downtown, Lavorata says. The village, he says, also received a grant to implement walkability improvements.

New eateries are also coming to the area. Lavorata says the owners of Mary Carroll’s in Babylon have purchased the former Chase Bank building on South Wellwood Avenue and will be converting it to a restaurant and bar.

In terms of housing styles in the village of Lindenhurst, there is something for everybody, says Jerry O’Neill of Coldwell Banker Harbor Light.

He says that includes everything from cottages to waterfront homes and vintage Colonials and Victorians to newly constructed single-family homes. The area is also home to The Villas at Narragansett, a 55-and-over community.

Prices in Lindenhurst, O’Neill says, range from around $250,000 to as much as $700,000 or $800,000. He says that in addition to the downtown area, which includes a variety of bars, restaurants and professional services, Lindenhurst has a healthy commercial district on Montauk Highway. Being a large waterfront community, he adds, Lindenhurst offers many marina-related businesses and services. There are also waterfront restaurants, some of which are accessible by boat.

Lindenhurst, which includes an unincorporated section, is home to Venetian Shores Park, a resident-only beach along the Great South Bay that features a playground, picnic areas and an interactive spray park. Village Square Park hosts a variety of recreational events and a summer concert series.



There is one condo on the market, for $369,000.



Between Aug. 1, 2016, and Sept. 14, 2017, there were 464 home sales with a median sale price of $285,000, according to the Multiple Listing Service of Long Island. The low price for that period was $102,500 and the high was $575,000. During that time period a year earlier, there were 391 home sales with a median sale price of $300,000. The price range was $85,000 to $530,000.



Most students attend Lindenhurst High School.


Town Babylon

Area 3.8 square miles

ZIP code 11757

Population 27,253

Me dian age 40.3

Median household income $83,532

Median home value $325,000

LIRR to NYC 57 to 74 minutes at peak

Monthly ticket $350

School district Lindenhurst


SOURCES: 2010 Census;; LIRR;

*Based on sales in the past six months, according to MLSLI




ANTHONY DRIVE After 244 days on the market, this four-bedroom, three-bathroom Contemporary sold for $40,500 less than its asking price. The 1989 home has an open floor plan that includes a great room with a fireplace, a formal dining room and an eat-in kitchen with granite countertops. The master suite, with a bathroom and balcony, is on the upper level with three additional bedrooms and a full bathroom. The 81-by-92-foot property, with taxes of $18,178, also has an attached two-car garage and back deck.



ADAMS AVENUE This four-bedroom, two-bathroom Colonial sold for $10,000 less than its asking price after 116 days on the market. The home, built in 1934, includes formal living and dining rooms. The eat-in kitchen boasts granite countertops and stainless steel appliances. One bedroom is on the main level, and three additional bedrooms plus a full bathroom are on the upper level. The 100-by-100-foot lot, with taxes of $9,851, also features a full basement and a detached two-car garage.



SOUTH 12TH STREET Originally listed for $283,000, this three-bedroom, one-bathroom Cape sold in May after 222 days on the market. Built in 1940, the house includes a living room with a fireplace, a kitchen and a formal dining room. The master bedroom is on the main level. The house boasts a full, unfinished basement. There’s also an attached 1 1⁄2- car garage and a workshop on the 85-by-100-foot property. The taxes are $9,456.



$289,000 This two-bedroom, one-bathroom ranch offers a living room, eat-in kitchen and sliders that open to a back deck. Taxes on the 50-by-100-foot property are $6,243. Anita Watterson and Lisa O’Donnell, Exit Realty Dreams, 516-456-2769, 516-815-6059



$389,000 This ranch, with three bedrooms and 1 1⁄2 bathrooms, includes a living room, formal dining room and granite eat-in kitchen with stainless steel appliances and cherry cabinetry. The 80-by-145-foot property also has a deck and attached one-car garage. Taxes are $11,801. George Metz, Charles Rutenberg Realty, 631-767-9188



$535,000 This four-bedroom, three-bathroom Colonial includes a granite kitchen, living room with a gas fireplace and master suite. The waterfront 38-by-80-foot property includes an attached one-car garage. Taxes: $15,879. Lisa Palermo, Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage, 631-921-9979

On Multiple Listings

Number of houses 123

Price range $147,030-$749,000

Tax range $4,804-$23,447

Latest Long Island News