This five-bedroom Lloyd Harbor Colonial, listed for $1.725 million, comes with a batting cage.
The 2.02-acre property also includes an outdoor stone fireplace, a pool with a waterfall and a basketball court.
"We are a pretty active family," says owner Renee Greco. "On warm summer nights, we like to cook in the kitchen outside, sit by the pool and swim with the kids, light a fire and watch TV under the pergola."
Residents also have the opportunity to join the Fiddlers Green Association. For a yearly fee of about $1,400, members have access to a private beach as well as sponsored events throughout the year.
In addition to the five bedrooms, there are three bathrooms and two half-bathrooms.
The house is listed with Shalini Schetty of Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty.