EntertainmentBooks

Readers' Pizza Hall of Fame

Cauliflower pizza at Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza

Cauliflower pizza at Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza Photo Credit: Yana Paskova

We asked you to name your favorite pizza spot on LI. You responded -- via facebook, email and on newsday.com -- with detailed reasons followed by more exclamation marks than one might think effective. We applaud your passion, and are happy to present your top picks. Hopefully they will inspire you to discover a new favorite. Or three.

AEGEAN PIZZA, Holbrook Readers say:

AEGEAN PIZZA, Holbrook

Readers say: "(Bleep Pizza) is way overrated and WAY over priced! Agean Pizza in the Sun Vet Mall in Holbrook blows it away! (And for half the price!)" --Rob Forres

ALBERT'S PIZZA, Ronkonkoma Readers say:
Photo Credit: Handout

ALBERT'S PIZZA, Ronkonkoma

Readers say: "Albert's Pizza in Ronkonkoma. Square pie. Case closed." --eemirror

Cauliflower pizza at Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza
Photo Credit: Yana Paskova

Cauliflower pizza at Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza

CAFE GINO, Westbury
Photo Credit: Handout

CAFE GINO, Westbury

COLOSSEO, Port Jefferson Readers say:

COLOSSEO, Port Jefferson

Readers say: "Pepperoni crisps up beautifully, sausage is sliced perfectly." --robvs ... "The best I've had so far for Sicilian." --pete480

LITTLE VINCENT'S, Lake Ronkonkoma Reader's say:
Photo Credit: Tom Benson

LITTLE VINCENT'S, Lake Ronkonkoma

Reader's say: "Little Vincent's Lake Ronkonkoma. Story over. There is no competition, period." --Michael Maccarrone

SALVATORE'S COAL OVEN PIZZERIA, Port Washington
Photo Credit: Michael Falco

SALVATORE'S COAL OVEN PIZZERIA, Port Washington

SATELITE PIZZA, Bayport Readers say:
Photo Credit: Handout

SATELITE PIZZA, Bayport

Readers say: "Satellite in Bayport. I have relatives who pack a bunch of their pies when they fly back to Florida." --tcbb

UMBERTO'S PIZZERIA AND RESTAURANT, New Hyde Park Readers
Photo Credit: Peter Dilauro

UMBERTO'S PIZZERIA AND RESTAURANT, New Hyde Park

Readers say: "Sicilian the absolute best!!!" -- Chuck Sonnenberg ... "Umberto's NHP, forget the rest. Regular or Sicilan" --Bob Busch

Well, we can't stop there. Here are other
Photo Credit: Newsday / Joan Reminick

Well, we can't stop there. Here are other places you love, all of which received multiple nominations: Alfredo's Pizzeria, Ridge | Alfredo's Pizzeria, Westbury| Amore Pizza, East Northport | Anton Pizzeria, Center Moriches | Bellagio Neighborhood Pizzeria, Farmingdale | Caffe Amici, Selden | Cervizzio's Pizza, Lindenhurst | Ciro's Pizzeria, East Meadow | Delfiore Pizza and Food Co., Patchogue | Fattusco's Pizza, Northport | Filetto's, East Northport | Galleria Pizza, Merrick | Gino's Pizzeria, Lynbrook | King Umberto, Elmont

Little Vincent's, Huntington | Mama Lisa, Mastic |
Photo Credit: Handout

Little Vincent's, Huntington | Mama Lisa, Mastic | Mama's Pizza, Copiague | Nino's Pizza, Oyster Bay | Raimo's Pizza, Amityville | Ralph's Pizza, Bayville | Rocco's Pizza, St. James | Vincent's, Lynbrook | Vinny Roma, Massapequa

More Entertainment

By using this site, you agree to our Privacy policy.

OK
Sorry to interrupt...

Your first 5 are free

Access to Newsday is free for Optimum customers.

Please enjoy 5 complimentary views to articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.

LOGIN SUBSCRIBE