78° Good Afternoon
78° Good Afternoon

'Salmon Fishing in the Yemen' is clumsy

Amr Waked, left, and Ewan McGregor star in

Amr Waked, left, and Ewan McGregor star in CBS Films' "Salmon Fishing in the Yemen." Photo Credit: MCT/

There's an off-handed joke about Asperger's syndrome in "Salmon Fishing in the Yemen" -- director Lasse Hallstrom's irony-free adaptation of Paul Torday's ironic novel -- and it makes you wonder if the film has a cognitive disorder of its own. After all, characters laugh at things that aren't funny. They fail to understand the perfectly obvious. They take umbrage with each other for no reason other than to advance the story's ridiculous premise -- one that Torday treated with tongue in cheek, but which Hallstrom ("Chocolat") takes perfectly seriously.

While both Emily Blunt and Ewan McGregor are enormously appealing actors, Hallstrom has made a movie that pretends it is something it's not -- namely, an intelligent romantic comedy.

Hallstrom's adaptation has as much in common with its source material as it does a can of tuna fish. The story: Harriet (Blunt) is a consultant working for British government publicist Patricia Maxwell (Kristin Scott Thomas, channeling "Absolutely Fabulous"), who's looking to spin some upbeat news out of the Middle East. So she assigns Harriet to help a wealthy Yemeni sheik (Amr Waked) stock the river he's created (by building a Hoover-sized dam) with salmon, so his impoverished people can enjoy the fly fishing they're always dreamed of. Harriet, whose boyfriend is off fighting in Afghanistan, is no dope, so she seeks out Dr. Alfred Jones (McGregor), one of the nation's leading ichthyologists, who thinks the whole scheme is insane. Which, of course it is, even though Jones comes to embrace it, especially after his wife (Rachael Stirling) leaves him and he apparently loses his mind.

The film has its charms -- Blunt, mostly, and McGregor, who turns in a wonderful performance. But "Salmon" goes belly up early, and getting to the end feels like a lot of swimming upstream.

PLOT A publicist and a fisheries expert help a Yemeni sheik angling to bring fly-fishing to his Mideast country. RATING PG-13 (some violence, sexual content and brief strong language)

CAST Ewan McGregor, Emily Blunt, Amr Waked, Kristin Scott Thomas


PLAYING AT Manhasset Cinemas, Malverne Cinema 4, Cinema Arts Centre, Huntington

BOTTOM LINE Get the hook: Clumsily unconvincing story has appealing stars, no clue.


We're revamping our Comments section. Learn more and share your input.

More Entertainment