60° Good Afternoon
60° Good Afternoon

'Wish I Was Here' review: Maybe not, Zach Braff

Mandy Patinkin, left, stars as Gabe and Zach

Mandy Patinkin, left, stars as Gabe and Zach Braff stars as Aiden in Braff's new comedy, "Wish I Was Here," the follow-up to his indie breakout hit "Garden State." Photo Credit: MCT

As he did in the much-praised "Garden State" (2004), actor Zach Braff ("Scrubs") returns to the director's chair for a bit of trope-juggling with the nonsensically titled "Wish I Was Here." What's it about? Everything and nothing. Seriously: If wishes were horses, one would have walked into the movie and told us what exactly Braff thought was going on.

What the viewer will likely think is that the screenwriters -- Braff and his brother Adam -- have a skewed sense of the dramatic. The nuclear family at the movie's center -- Adrian (Braff), wife Sarah (Kate Hudson), son Tucker (Pierce Gagnon) and daughter Grace (Joey King) -- are intended to represent a contemporary state of American economic/spiritual stasis. What they come off as is a clinically depressed sitcom cast. The kids go to a Los Angeles yeshiva only because grandpa Gabe (Mandy Patinkin) insists, and pays; Adrian and Sarah are, at best, reluctant Jews. Adrian is pursuing an acting career that's going less than nowhere, while Sarah works a soul-crushing job at the local water department. It's hard to sympathize much with anyone, but particularly Adrian, because he -- like his trailer-dwelling-genius brother Noah (Josh Gad) -- practices a form of whiny narcissism that all the Cat Power/ Cold Play/Aaron Embry songs in the world can't relieve.

There's an absurdist streak running through "Wish I Was Here" that helps some of the humor but also makes a lot of jokes feel forced. Gabe is dying; the children are home-schooled ("What are we, Amish?"); Adrian takes the kids on a spirit quest that seems to confuse them; Grace cuts off her hair in a gesture of Orthodox solidarity. And Noah finds his soul mate at Comic-Con. There's a lot going on, little of which rings the emotional bell Braff intends. For all its good intentions and easy nature, there's an abrasively blinkered worldview in "Wish I Was Here" that leaves one cold.

PLOT Father/husband/actor finds himself at a crossroads.

RATING R (language and some sexual content)

CAST Zach Braff, Kate Hudson, Joey King, Mandy Patinkin


BOTTOM LINE Offbeat, sometimes funny, but emotionally overwrought


We're revamping our Comments section. Learn more and share your input.

More Entertainment