63° Good Morning
63° Good Morning

Nick Kroll, John Mulaney talk ‘Oh, Hello on Broadway,’ more

Comedians Nick Kroll and John Mulaney are doing

Comedians Nick Kroll and John Mulaney are doing their crotchety, 70-something Upper West Side characters at the Lyceum Theatre in "Oh, Hello on Broadway." Credit: Getty Images / Dave Kotinsky

It’s good to have an alter ego, as comedians Nick Kroll and John Mulaney know quite well. They’ve been playing crotchety, 70-something Upper West Siders Gil Faizon and George St. Geegland for a decade — first at a stand-up gig and on Kroll’s Comedy Central series “Kroll Show,” then Off-Broadway, on a national tour. Now — and they’re more shocked by this than anybody — they’ve brought their characters to the Lyceum Theatre in “Oh, Hello on Broadway.”

Or “Br’d-WAYYY,” as the two old codgers pronounce it. Running through Jan. 8, the experience is part stand-up, part farce, part talk show (during each performance they call someone up onstage, often a celebrity, from Seth Meyers to Cuba Gooding Jr.). And the audience, made up of “comedy nerds, theater dorks and children whose parents have made a severe mistake,” as Gil describes it, roars.

Newsday contributor Joseph V. Amodio recently chatted with Kroll, 38, and Mulaney, 34, on a conference call.

Excuse me if I sound distracted. It’s just that there’s a leak in my apartment. As we speak, water is dripping down my bathroom wall from somewhere above so . . .

Kroll: Full disclosure, that’s George and Gil. They clog up toilets all over the city.

Mulaney: They try to flush the Sunday Times every weekend.

I shoulda known. By the way, I love the inspiration for these two characters — how you saw two older gents at The Strand bookstore downtown buying Alan Alda’s autobiography and they . . . really captured your attention.

Mulaney: We were looking for a way to host a stand-up show and they were . . . a perfect pair. We could tell they’d been joined at the hip for years.

Do you do that a lot — see people from afar and imagine their back stories?

Mulaney: We had more time to do that back then. Now we get lots of photos every day on Twitter from people . . . spotting other Georges and Gils around the country.

Kroll: They’re everywhere.

Mulaney: There are female Georges and Gils, too.

Kroll: But the show is also about Broadway, and New York. We’re history buffs, and love the city of the ’60s, ’70s and ’80s. And Ed Koch . . .

Mulaney: It was a time when sweaty politicians yelled at reporters and reporters yelled back. I pine for that now a little.

The Long Island Rail Road even gets a shout-out in the show. George St. Geegland’s novel about commuters is entitled “Next Stop, Ronkonkoma.”

Mulaney: I don’t think you can pass by the Ronkonkoma stop more than once without the name leaving a lasting impression. It sounds like an ancient tribe of . . .

Kroll: . . . of Islanders fans.

Mulaney: Yeah . . . that went to Adelphi.

You two met as students at Georgetown. It’s hard to imagine you hangin’ with the Jesuits but . . . OK.

Kroll: There wasn’t a ton of focus on the arts there, but, because of that, we had a ton of opportunities to get onstage.

Mulaney: We met when I was a freshman and auditioned for the improv group. Nick was a senior and the director.

Kroll: And I’ve been holding that power over him ever since.

Does doing the show on Broadway feel . . . different?

Mulaney: It’s very rare air to be in. We started rehearsals at a studio with other Broadway shows down the hall . . . like “The Front Page.” It was flattering.

Kroll: Everything’s on a grander scale now. Our sets and . . .

The massive tuna-sandwich puppet.

Kroll: You have to spend a lotta money to see these shows. We understand that. We wanted to make it worthwhile.

You sometimes invite celebrities onstage. Who have you really clicked with?

Mulaney: It was great having Alan Alda opening night.

Kroll: He was so funny and sharp. We don’t plan anything. It’s a blast, getting to talk with these legends. Like Whoopi Goldberg, who did her show at the Lyceum years ago. Or Stephen Colbert.

Mulaney: Former Police Commissioner Ray Kelly was surprising. We thought we’d have to prep him on the characters. But he’s the former police commissioner . . . so he was like, “I know exactly who you guys are and what to do.”

Kroll: Aziz Ansari came on with his dad. We didn’t have a guest one night and Katie Couric was in the crowd so we pulled her onstage. You just never know. Our goal is to make every show a new experience.

Has doing the show made you think about what you’ll be like in your 70s?

Mulaney: A lot. On two-show days, we’re in makeup for, like, seven hours. You have to stare at yourself as an old man in the mirror . . . which is a good exercise. More people should do it. Makes you want to eat better. And have fewer regrets.

Kroll: Yeah, hopefully, we’ll have taken better care of our bodies than George and Gil have.

More Entertainment