Good Morning
Good Morning

Coal miner Shane Bruce falls just short on 'American Idol'

Coal miner Shane Bruce sings "Hallelujah," which, because he's 19, he knows from "Shrek."

He has an almost old-world tone and shapes his notes fully. Everyone's dead quiet listening. Afterward he says "I usually hit that better."

I liked him, and his voice. The judges are all like "not the best audition we've ever seen," and tell him he's not ready yet. I don't know. I'd have sent him through.

Afterward he's near tears, his family is sad and quiet and tells him he's still their idol. It's actually a well-produced segment, with some real emotion. He seems like a great person and I hope he comes back next season.

Agree? Disagree? Tell us in the comments below, or on Twitter using #ndidol.

More Entertainment