Elise Testone up next on "American Idol," singing Alicia Keys' "No One." Strong song choice, fits her throaty vocal quality well.
Starts to feel a bit repetitive as it goes on -- problem for her is by the end of the night nobody is going to remember this, it's well done but she needs to wow people to stay on the show.
"I got my first goosies of the night," says Jennifer Lopez. Wants to see her smile more, "your eyes come alive... it's like a light bulb."
Steven Tyler just repeats, "I love you, man." Randy Jackson is glad she stuck with the melody, "great lesson in restraint for you."
Agree? Disagree? Tell us in the comments below, or on Twitter using #ndidol.