Overcast 58° Good Afternoon
Overcast 58° Good Afternoon

Guitar girl Holly Harden and 'fearless' Mallorie Haley tops on 'American Idol'

People arrive in Atlanta for Season 9 auditions

People arrive in Atlanta for Season 9 auditions for "American Idol." Photo Credit: Fox

Holly Harden, in an outlandish 'human guitar' outfit is next on 'American Idol'. I think the only contestants with props I ever thought were good were the roller-skating waitress friends from a few years ago.... Mary J. Blige is cracking up already, "You Ain't Woman Enough to Take My Man."

Holy cow, she can actually sing; husky voice, good phrasing -- my gosh, ditch the idiot outfit! Simon calls her fun, likes her personality; Randy thinks she's funny, Kara says she's a "ballsy girl." Blige just says no, but everyone else says yes, and who would've guessed, she's through to Hollywood!

Mallorie Haley sings "Piece of My Heart," and she's good right off the bat. Soulful voice, confident, no games about her, just flat out can sing. Blige calls it "great," the "best vocal I heard." Kara likes how she knows who she is, Randy calls her beautiful, Simon says "you were fearless."

Did you like Holly Harden, or find her silly? How about Mallorie Haley, something special or just average? Click on 'add a comment' at the bottom of this post and tell us

>> PHOTOS: Click here to see contestants and celebrity judges from this year's 'American Idol' audition rounds

>> FUN: Test your memory -- how many of the winners and top finalists can you name, from each season of 'American Idol'?

>> MORE: Read all of our 'American Idol' posts, and put in your two cents

Fox photo

More Entertainment