Good Evening
Good Evening

Haley Reinhart has a hold on the judges on 'American Idol'

Haley Reinhart singing "You've Really Got a Hold on Me," next on "American Idol." Vamps down the stairs in a short black shorts with a white tuxedo top. 

I don't know, this just doesn't feel right to me. The look, the pick, her performance. She's not a relaxed type of person, and this song needs a coolness she doesn't have. I like her tone, but it just doesn't work for me.

Randy Jackson said it started rough, but tells her she was good after the middle, "exactly the type of singer we always thought you were." Steven Tyler says it touched his heart, "you don't look a day over fabulous," and says he liked her growl, too. Jennifer Lopez likes her effortless control of her voice.


More Entertainment