Naomi Gillies sings Aerosmith's "Cryin'" in a totally stripped-down, slow way, then soars a bit more on the chorus. She's totally interesting, has great tone and good presence.
"You belted it out," says Steven Tyler. "The minute you opened your mouth I was like 'wow'" adds Jennifer Lopez.
Hyperactive baby-faced Ben Harrison, who looks a bit like a pudgy Doogie Howser crossed with Chucky, does Queen's "Somebody to Love."
Hmm, he's actually kind of compelling, with a crazy falsetto and totally dramatic, but somebody you'll remember. Blows Lopez a kiss at the end, but doesn't make it.
Agree? Disagree? Tell us in the comments below, or on Twitter using #ndidol.