Paul McDonald, Haley Reinhart or Stefano Langone are about to get kicked off "American Idol."
First time all season I've felt like the bottom three was exactly the way it should be; as far as I'm concerned, these should be the next three finalists eliminated.
I'll be sad when Haley leaves because she has mad talent and tries interesting things, but she's definitely not better than the people who are safe tonight.
And Haley is safe! Nice. And the first guy kicked off the finals is Paul McDonald!
Sends us out with "Maggie May" at the request of a teary Jennifer Lopez. Definitely his best song; problem was he's never gotten better.
He's so relaxed and such a pro up there. I'l miss his happy-go-lucky smile and his greetings to the crowd at the beginning of his songs.