Siobhan Magnus has to save what's been another pretty blah show on "American Idol," singing "Superstition." Miley Cyrus says she really sticks out for her, she "has something really interesting about her," loves the "swagger" to her voice.
She's looking a bit like early Madonna, and her silky voice is just belting out the song. She really knows how to go for it; big voice -- not amazing so far, but strong. It's totally her own song, too. Swallowing some of her lyrics; and of course the patented huuuuuge scream towards the end, but it fits the song pretty well.
Randy says she's fearless and that he "thought it was great, loved it." Ellen loved it, too.Kara likes her comfort level, not your best but what an amazing last note. Simon says the screaming at the end may be getting old, and she didn't hit the notes as well as last week.
Simon tells everyone to "start pushing yourself," and that tonight "was not a good night."
TALK: Was Siobhan Magnus great, or is the screaming getting old? Click on "Add a comment" at the bottom of this post, or e-mail me and I'll post it for you.